Key Spiritual Care Skills Interfaith Chaplains


January 2025

 

Key Spiritual Care Skills; 2025

 

Cathy Hasty,

RN (ret.) M.Div. Th.M.

CE-ACPE, BCC/APC,

LCMHCS

AAPC Diplomate

Ordained CC (DOC) 

 

Welcome to this year of learning and service. As you read, please highlight any areas where you would like to engage in further discussion.

 

As chaplains, we hold a unique and demanding responsibility to establish trust with strangers at the most vulnerable moments of their lives, often within the first few minutes of introduction. Our role involves responding to death, trauma, births, challenging medical diagnoses, and life-saving surgeries. At these pivotal moments, we serve as faithful witnesses to people’s lives as they navigate both suffering and triumph. Our goal is to deepen our skills and understanding of how to cultivate trustworthiness, reliability, competence, and professionalism.

 

This call necessitates investigation and practices of self-trust, community trust, and trust in our understanding of the divine or the essence of our “spiritual orienting system.” Spiritual orienting systems encompass a diverse array of ways individuals make meaning and sense of their experiences.

 

Chaplains develop a comprehensive understanding of spirituality and its essence as being human. While Christian references are incorporated into my writing, I intend to honor and acknowledge the equally valid and profound wisdom found in other religious and spiritual traditions.

 

One definition of spirituality is the art of connection. In spiritual care, we connect with individuals and pay attention to the ways they connect to themselves, their communities, their sacred beliefs, and their stories of connection and disconnection, spanning all the spaces in between. To be trustworthy to a wide range of people requires us to open ourselves up to a broader understanding of what is sacred, often transcending our preconceived notions and imagination.  

 

 

Your special contribution to the health care team issues forth from your journey and expertise in many areas,  with special emphasis on your engagement with spirituality.  You bring some larger reality to the conversations which some people call by many names:God, Allah, Great Spirit and which others don’t name and still others frame as human nature. 

 

The goal is to broaden our ability to speak into the space beyond our own faith and religion into the great mystery of what has no final name, what has sometimes been called the soul or the spirit.   

 

You are building a sturdy reliable sense of self, using that awareness to forge and reforge relationships especially in highly pressurized  contexts.  Being trustworthy includes attending to the vacillation in your capacity to remain study under pressure.  To remain sturdy, or anti-fragile, or resilient,  will mean applying manageable processes and practices of grounding yourself, of reflection, of self care, of keeping small commitments to yourself.    

 

There will be discomfort as you tickle your growing edges do the work towards becoming more trustworthy.   

 

The work includes going into the edges of your discomfort and exploring how to be present to yourself in hard times. There will be practices and habits that require time and energy and commitment.   You have to believe you are worth the effort of being invested in yourself. You have to believe you and your calling are worth the effort to build deeper relationships.  You have to believe that is it possible to be caring to self and other and your call; and that is enough to be good enough. 

 

Perfection will not serve you and neither will self protection.  

 

We spend time discovering the both/and and checking our impulse to think in the either/or.  

 

The certified educators work with you, individually and as a group, to hone just the right trials and skills to temper and strengthen the metal of making good decisions for yourself and others in the overarching context of your belief system.   We work closely with other members of team towards increasing your capacity, your skills, your awareness, your professional identity.  

 

The curriculum is a metal smith's guide, shaping and honing your trustworthiness into a resilient and reliable instrument.  The honing is through challenges and support, transforming and adding to all the gifts you already bring.   We build capacities to be more fully present and to pay attention.  We add knowledge and skills, such as verbal and non-verbal communication, actions, assessments and rituals.  As we journey together, we broaden our understanding of ourselves and the complexity of the world around us.  

 

We’ll explore pieces of the complexity of listening/attending, empathic reflection, conflict resolution/transformation, crisis management, emotional availability, humility, self disclosure, use of power and authority, collaboration, boundaries, holding silence, being a non anxious and non-judgmental presence, tolerating anxiety, of integrating our spiritual orienting systems and our practice.  *What was once referred to in many circles as “theology” and “theological” has been updated with SOS referencing spiritual orienting systems to begin to address diversity, inclusion and equity of people and cultures that are not theistic.  

 

 

COMMUNICATION: 

 

Excellent communication skills are essential to building a spiritual connection, to a healing relationship and to being professional chaplain.  It is not all about our words.  It is about being fully present on behalf of the other person in ways that invite conscious and unconscious self knowing to come together in such a way that the system learns to recognize its own organization.  In this state, if there is change, it is self generated as people come to reflect on how they create problems and how they may resolve them.

We are always communicating, even with our absence or with our silence, with what is said and left unsaid, and mostly with what our body communicates.  

 

Often people think they listen and communicate well, yet how do you know when you are NOT communicating well?  Often we overestimate our communication skills. Someone may sound all the right notes and yet not create the subtle music that is spiritual care.  The most recent research is confirming what we have always proposed - that safety, belonging, dignity, community are essential to human thriving.  There is a co -regulation when the human instrument resonates with others in mysterious ways.   This resonance has an impact on health.  

 

In conversation the speaker attempts to communicate about public or private inner states and conditions through micro expressions, words, tone, pace, non verbals, expressions and behaviors. As a designated listener we take in and respond to small parts of what the speaker presents.  We respond to the parts that are understandable and manageable through the filters of our own interior world.   With careful training, we can broaden our filters to allow in more information, to be more fully present, to pay attention with more accuracy.  

 

We get out of the way so they can hear their own deepest wisdom.   When people feel HEARD, they feel belonging and care which adds to healing at a cellular level.  

 

“When the work’s done right, with no fuss or boasting, ordinary people say, Oh, we did it ourselves.” Lao Tzu

 

 

The skills presented in this writing are like the “musical notes” of spiritual care.  You may already know the scales and the notes; you may compose music with people.   There may be types of communication that you know better than anyone in the room.  You have much to teach and we can all expand our repertoire.

 

Many parts of the sent message are ignored or changed by us as listeners.  The human brain tries to compress information and quickly makes us quit listening.  

 

We can all widen the net of our listening and responding abilities.  

 

No listener can know  the complexity of what is inside a speaker.  Words are one small and imprecise way to point to a shared reality.  Art, music, actions, body signals are other ways to evoke a shared reality.  Words are always an approximation; they point to a shared experience.  Words are always more or less inaccurate.  Therefore misunderstandings occur.   As listeners we use a variety of methods to construct,  understand and respond to what people are telling us, both with their word and beyond words.  Numerous research studies have given the following information about communication: 

 

  1.  Words contain 7% of what is communicated when there is any complexity. 

 

2. Tone, pace, etc. of voice contains 38%, either along with or without words

3. Body language, dress, contains 55% of total communication 4. 

 

 

 

When there are incongruities between the spoken and the non-spoken message, people will believe the communication that is nonverbal over verbal 93% of time. 

 

Western culture has placed a high priority on language, on words, on reason so many people are skeptical of the non verbal.  We think we are more rational than we are.  

 

Non-verbal communication communicate so many messages, so many nuances, that words cannot capture.    

 

There is an essential 4th item that was not included in the research: cultural assumptions, cultural lens and the necessity of cultural humility.  

 

Essential stance:  WE must suspend what we think we know in order to learn.  This is inherently uncomfortable.  We need to hold on to a beginners mind which means we embrace uncertainty and let go of some control.  

 

 

For example part of the non-verbal message may be the context, the power and the authority or lack of authority of the speaker.  

 

If we don’t trust a speaker then all the verbalization in the world is not convincing!  

 

For example, non verbals may include reading some credential that is meaningful to the listener.  The title “chaplain” may create a non-verbal communication to some listeners before you ever open your mouth.    

 

Innately we are attentive to non-verbal communication from the moment we are born.  Babies respond to intonation, eye movement and sound.  As children, we spend the majority of our attention decoding the messages in nonverbal cues that a speaker gives to us about his or her internal world.  When there is any inconsistency or incongruence between verbal and non-verbal, we tend to trust the nonverbal cues.  

 

Yet we have few opportunities as professional communicators to become more aware of and to be reminded about where we are incongruent and where our presence rings with authenticity.  Often due to the power differential, patients, families and staff do not give us accurate feedback about how well we listen.   

 

We need colleagues and peers to help us develop and hone our awareness and skills in this area.  

 

Listening begins before a word is spoken.  You walk in a room and see cards, the way the person is dressed, the expressions.  You sense the movements,  the smells, hear the sounds.  There are minute and fleeting ways that the sender and receiver take in the initial impressions given by such things as micro facial expression, context, clothing, posture, gestures, use of space, intonation, foreshadowing from others and surroundings.  

 

Listening continues as the receiver hears the multiple levels of communication and meaning and in the exchange give and take as there are responses back to the speaker.  The listener gives back information to the speaker to check out comprehension, to correct misunderstanding and to communicate such responses as understanding, acceptance or judgement.  The ability to experience and to communicate understanding, acceptance, misunderstanding and confrontation are some of the important parts of listening and speaking.

 

There are many different types of responses and interventions that you as a listener offer in a conversation.  

 

In settings with people with whom  you share a history, you may know how to respond more easily, more intuitively.

Intuition is a great gift, developed over time with feedback from practice.  It is a form of guessing; however it can be wrong.  Humility is necessary, particularly when someone is in a vulnerable situation such as health care. 

 

Theory, education, practice comes in when our intuition is lacking.   We work to hone our intuition, to inform it and strengthen it, deepen it to create more healing connection.  Through dialogue and reflection, we unpack our intuition to see where it is grounded in data or in mis conception.  We learn as we confirmation of where our intuitive natural responses are on target or distorted.   Your peer group and your supervisors can be great resources because often patients, family and staff cannot or will not give you effective feedback.   They tend to vote with their feet; they may simply withdraw or ignore you.  

 

All of us bring both conscious and unconscious goals to conversations, some of which are mutually exclusive.  For example we often want to help and think that means making the person feel better.  To that end we may give premature advice or glib reassurance or direction.  Advice and reassurance can backfire; sometimes these make people feel isolated, disrespected and frustrated.   A person may take care of us by apparently finding advice helpful, using their valuable energy to sooth our egos.  Or they may quickly agree, just to get rid of us and get on with their lives.  

 

Our desire to help, to solve and to fix OFTEN interferes with their desire to express the depths of their experience and have a deeper sense of communion and solidarity.  

 

We may unconsciously have a goal to be seen as “knowledgeable” or “faithful” or “nice.”   Then we nod and smile when we don’t fully understand something, fearing that our ignorance will be obvious or we will present a doubt.  Again this can get in the way of the person experiencing a sense of accompaniment in their suffering.  

 

Our experience, self-awareness, knowledge, insight and wisdom all influence the contents of our responses through the timing and selection of the many ways to respond, the congruence of the body language, vocal tone, pace and other nonverbal qualities. 

 

You may chose to use some responses and to avoid other responses, depending on the goals you have for the relationship, in the conversation and as the Spiritual care giver.  What you want to communicate, with both your words and your use of your self, depends on your belief system-both conscious and unconscious .  You may want to invite the person to feel heard, understood, accepted, challenged and ultimately loved.  You may want the person to change their life style to be closer to your beliefs or to give you affirmation, acceptance and nurture.   You may want the person to make you feel good.   

 

And we all have unconscious motivations that require examination and adjustment.  

 

What is important to you, maybe related to the core theological/philosophical/spiritual orienting/broader messages,  that you seek to communicate in your Spiritual relationships?  What are the non-verbal ways that you can embody those messages? 

 

What core messages are more covert than overt, given through the non verbals or the body? 

 

BARRIERS TO COMMUNICATION IN A HOSPITAL SETING AND IN OTHER STRESSFUL SITUATIONS: 

 

Spiritual care providers may underestimate the power that their internal state, their level of comfort, of security, of freedom, has in transformation and healing.  This security comes through in the warmth, attentive listening, accurate response and compassionate presence. 

 There is a “co regulation” or a dis- regulation of internal worlds that occurs far below our awareness.   

 

“All I did was listen” or “it was nothing, I was just listening”?  is a common litany.    

YET we know from the research on loneliness that people are “dying” to have quality relationships.  People need a compassionate and knowledgeable person to over-hear what they are saying about themselves and their lives, someone to serve as a reliable interpretive guide as they explore their stories: these are essential to health and healing.  

 

YES, People are dying from isolation.  

 

Social isolation and loneliness  increase the risks of “physical and mental conditions: high blood pressure, heart disease, obesity, a weakened immune system, anxiety, depression, cognitive decline, Alzheimer's disease, and even death.”  

 

We co construct a safe space to reveal and explore their most deeply held beliefs, values, and feelings and experience a genuine sense of acceptance and community.  

 

In that sacred space, that sanctuary, we enter into their world and respond with authentic interest and grounded feeling.  In that context, when there is honesty and empathy, grace and truth, people are liberated towards fuller, more abundant life.  They tap their own healing wisdom as they are invited to experience the joy of free and spontaneous self expression moment by moment.   To extend the music metaphor we are helping them as they compose their own unique melody which is part of the symphony of the community of God/higher power.  

 

Remember a time when you revealed something about yourself to someone else you trusted and admired and received the experience of graceful acceptance.  The places within yourself where you have discovered acceptance and found wisdom, you are able to visit with others without anxiety or impatience.  

 

All of us have areas of our lives, parts of ourselves, that we habitually avoid, including memories, feelings and thoughts associated with fear, shame, sadness, death, anger, disgust and anxiety.  We have blind spots and distortions in our understanding and awareness.   We seek safety and avoid threat in historical ways that interfere with current connections.  These blind spots and distortions are places where we are not trustworthy.  We are reactive, which may come out in a wide variety of ways.  

 

Parts of our lives are largely unexamined.  When someone inadvertently moves too close to our unprocessed pain or blindness, we scuttle away, attack, avoid or distract.  Where we lack awareness, knowledge and insight concerning our own identity and internal life, we are poorly equipped to help others to understand themselves. In these places we cannot tolerate hearing people tell their stories and we are not faithful witnesses to their deepest experiences.  Part of our mandate is to sacrifice our comfort in the ongoing process of becoming more com-passionate, more faithful care givers.  

 

Listening to suffering is a sacrificial act; we sacrifice our comfort.  

 

We do not speak words of healing from our wounds but from our scars.   It is those parts of ourselves to which we have been reconciled that are our “cracks where the light gets in.” (Leonard Cohen, Anthem) 

People, both care givers and care receivers, both consciously and unconsciously, protect themselves by sending messages that are incongruent in terms of verbal and the nonverbal communication.  

 

Incongruence is a red light to communication.  

 

As Spiritual care givers, we often let people know if we are “safe” or not by the way we respond to the complexity of their incongruent messages and the level of noise (incongruence, ambiguity)  in our own communication. 

 

Our work of integration, containing our own reactivity, comes from our ability to know and accept ourselves; our humanity, our fragility, our failings and our gifts. We bring  our ability to tolerate ambiguity, confusion, the unknown.  We hold space for the questions, the mystery; these are part of the art of Spiritual care.  

 

Often our blind spots in this regard are more obvious to others than it is to ourselves.   

 

We encounter aspects in others and ourselves that are threatening, "unacceptable" or unfamiliar.   We experience various blocks to our natural ability to relate and lose our ability to connect, to listen and to respond helpfully. 

 

In the beginning, people are often afraid or hopeless about reflecting or looking deeply at their motivations or feelings.  Out of the belief that humanity is bad or sinful, the deepest parts of the self are suspicious and “should” be suppressed, ignored or corrected.  Also people lack the space, support, education and skill to reflect upon their lives.  Without practice,  people develop few resources or experiences where they have encountered the experiences in the inner world with some sense of grace and truth and integration. Therefore they fear what they will find through such exploration.   

 

Our life work is to explore the inner territory of our lives and the exterior territory of our world thoroughly so that we can accompany people faithfully and courageously on their spiritual journeys.   The more diversity and complexity we have discovered, the farther we can go with a wider range of people.    Each of us is attracted to particular aspects of this journey.  One way to define our call is at the intersection of our deepest passion and the world’s greatest need.   The most difficult is to discern our deepest passion for there will always be more need than we can meet. 

 

Where would these understanding be compatible, incompatible, irrelevant with your own “orienting system” which may be related to your theological or religious understanding? 

 

Crisis often brings to the surface deeply held values, beliefs or emotions that uncover vulnerable or dysfunctional parts of who we are.   For example, we may revert back to previously held “superstitions” or magical thinking.   These parts of our inner world may surprise and even disappoint us.  When we experience feelings, thoughts and behaviors that are unfamiliar we may fear exposure.  We may become confused or overwhelmed because our inner lives are complex and dynamic.  Our thoughts and feelings are often ambiguous and sometimes conflicted.  We fear attack, blame and shame.  If we let ourselves express our deepest passion, we fear that we will destroy someone with our hatred or be destroyed by someone who hates us.   Our world with it’s assumptions may be upended.  By confronting us with the inadequacy of our worldview, crisis can propel us on the inner journey.  

 

          Crisis creates sensory overload, lack of concentration, difficulty with memory, a heightened sense of threat, etc.  "I can't think straight..."  The rollercoaster of highs and lows affects our understanding of ourselves, our identity.   

 

          Language is always an approximate and inadequate representational system to communicate the complex inner life.  Since our inner world is mysterious and complex, words are even more inadequate. The meanings assigned to certain words have complex and emotionally charged connotations; especially religious words such as saved, evangelism, sin, etc.  

 

What is of interest out of all these reflections?

 

 

Here is a  list of specific skills and interventions for Spiritual care:

 

 

Casual welcoming social conversation, which includes such things as introductions, small talk, social connections, associations with public information. One under-rated skill in Spiritual care is the ability to start a conversation that demonstrates hospitality and which helps people feel at ease, creating an atmosphere of relaxed warmth, in the midst of relative spiritual authority.  

 

As we enter a space, people are "breathing us in" through the opening impressions we make in introductions and beginning conversations.  People who are patients and family members in the hospital can feel uncomfortable, awkward, inferior, and irritable, which may be related to self-doubt and uncertainty.  

 

This is a foreign land. 

 

They can wonder if they are "not doing something right" or they are stupid in this foreign environment.  They may react to their helplessness with hostility, rejection, withdrawal or exaggerated politeness.  As chaplains, we are on our familiar home turf...or at least that is how the patient or family may see it!  

 

One of the first spiritual acts is to put the person at ease, to let them know who we are, why we are here in their room or meeting them in a waiting room and what is expected of them.  This occurs in many contexts some of which are complex.  We need to meet people where they are which can mean remaining neutral while we assess the situation.  

 

*Exercise:  Practice your introduction.   Listen to others introduce themselves and imagine what it would be like to meet them, what it would be like for them to meet your family and friends when you are in crisis.  Talk about how you would modify this introduction in various situations, such as a crisis, a death, a referral? 

 

2. NON-verbal expressions:  Silence, nonspecific verbalizations, use of body posture or facial expressions: You enter a room with a certain posture and expression in your eyes and around your mouth.  These non-verbal presentations can encourage an initial connection with the person or they can give people messages about what you want, (i.e. “I am happy and I need for you to be happy." Or  “This is a serious conversation.”)  

 

During the conversation, you offer general "ums" and "ahs" that encourage elaboration, smooth silences or express your own anxiety.  These apparently small expressions are important and often communicate volumes about the your, the listener's,  unconscious.  They give the speaker a green light or a red light to continue to express what they are expressing.  When the chaplain is relatively calm (non anxious) , responsive and emotionally available, the physical presence of the chaplain can offer a reality based supportive environment.  The care-receiver is able to pick up on the structure, security and depth of the interior world of the chaplain through numerous non-verbal cues. Comfort with silence AND the ability to discern the other person's comfort with silence are powerful tools.  

 

  •  Exercise:  
  •  Practice introducing yourself to a stranger whose room you have entered as a chaplain?
  •  Share what it is like when are you comfortable with silence. 
  •   How long is a comfortable silence?  
  •  When are you uncomfortable with silence?  How do you read the “quality” of a silence?  Are you aware when you are filling up the silence in awkward situations?   Share your frequent nonspecific verbalizations and facial expressions that you use when you are trying to listen without saying anything in particular.  What do you seek to communicate with these expressions?  Ask your partner or friends is they recognize any characteristic patterns of  non-specific responses or distracting responses you make.   
  •  What is the initial non-verbal message that you want to send?

 

3.  a. Clean Language is a way of  honoring a person’s exact words as closely as possible to the way they are said.  You will be learning more about this relatively new way of listening.  For now, one response to a comment is to join the person with “ And,” then repeat their exact words, in their pace, pause to see if they continue, or ask either “what kind of…” or is there anything else about… one piece of their comments. 

 

For example: 

Someone says “ I came to the hospital with pain.” and I might say, “And you came to the hospital with pain. (pause) And when you came to the hospital with pain, is there anything else about come to the hospital?”

 

This sounds awkward yet people overhear themselves differently when we are precise with their comments.  You will get more training in Clean Language and other models of listening.  

 

 

 

b. Paraphrase, Reflect or restate the Content: The main facts, key words or phrases that have been spoken can be used exactly or rephrased back to the person speaking to offer confirmation and clarification.  This reflection may stand alone with a brief repetition or be preceded with a preface, a stem, a warm up, such as:

And “this is hard”…

You are saying that...

You are telling me that...

So you’re saying…

What I am hearing...

What I hear you saying is…

And with (repeat key words), what else do you know…

 

A simple and genuine restatement 

  • *uses the person’s key words - not always the last words.  
  • *EXAMPLE:  Someone says “it’s hard to be here.”  You might pause, let that sink in and respond with “and it’s hard to be here.” (in the same tone, pace and gesture they used) 
  • * “And what kind of “hard” is that “hard?” 
  • *OR “And is there anything else about it being “hard?” 

can be a safe and effective way to listen, 

is an avenue to explore aspects of the issues presented, 

gives an opportunity for the people speaking to overhear themselves and 

is a way to allow time for the chaplain to think.  

 

The exact restatement can be especially helpful in situations where any assumption or interpretation at all may be hurtful or where the person is highly activated.  Also this works when you have lost your own train of thought!

 

This technique was given a bad name when non-directive listening was the current fad. When I was a student nurse I over used  the stem, "what I hear you saying is..." in a mental institution in eastern N.C.  I know I overused it when the “patient” asked if I had a hearing problem!   

 

c. A reflection that is a paraphrase or interpretation of the meaning of the message.  You are making more of a leap than with an exact restatement because you are changing the words to attempt to explore the intent of the comments, the context or the implications of the comments.  

 

  You seem to be saying...

Do you mean...

The way you say that makes me think...

The timing of your comment makes me wonder…

This may include an offering of possible feelings and needs.  We will be covering feelings, faux feelings and needs more extensively as we explore non violent communication.  

*Exercise: A patient is telling you a long involved story about a dog that was almost hit by a car.  You know that he has been re-scheduled for surgery that morning.  What are some possible interpretations that you might offer?

 

4. QUESTIONS 

The use of the appropriate, productive, and congruent question is a valuable skill.   The chaplain uses questions as part of selecting which content, facts and information require expansion for understanding and Spiritual intervention.  Yet asking questions can become an overused and potentially negative intervention coming out of anxiety and the need for control.  People feel interrogated by too many questions.  Questions can be used to change the subject when the listener becomes anxious or confused, to invade private space without invitation, to make hidden statements, to give directions or to buy time.  Questions are often used when a simple statement would be a better intervention.  Here are a few types of questions:  

 

4 a. The productive question that accesses "free information" is relevant to the subject that is being presented, follows the agenda of the speaker rather than the agenda of the listener, and/or assists the speaker to move more deeply into the subject.  Speakers include references and side comments that are sometimes vague, unconscious clues to what is important.  Sometimes as listeners we make assumptions about what a vague or ambiguous comment means.  Often we are wrong in our assumptions.  Productive questions include asking the speaker to expand on the implicit content by allowing the person to state the meaning, feeling tone or implications of a particular content within this particular context.  For example, people often give "free" information about their faith life when questioned about their cliques and vague references to God.

 

Examples of possible introductions to open ended questions:

Who has been helpful to you in similar situations?

  What did you mean when you said...

What did you think about...

* Exercise: Sally is a 24 year old female admitted for chronic stomach pains.  As she is talking, she says:  "I'm not sure what is wrong with me.  I have had these terrible pains in my stomach ever since I lost my job.  My mother says it's just my nerves.  I guess I should just turn it over to the Lord."  What parts of this statement could you follow up on as free information?

 

5 b.  The productive question can help a person fill in missing information that may refer to facts, persons, feelings, events, or associations.  This can also include exploring the deeper meaning behind superficial, incomplete sentences or "throwaway" comments; these are often rich with unconscious meaning.  A common throwaway comment may be found in religious cliques which can be taken seriously and explored for their meaning. In order to frame a good question, it is important to remember that you have time to create several options in your head before you speak. But if your question must be perfect, you tend to miss the opportunity for a timely question.

 

One form of a productive question comes out of Non Violent Communication (Marshal Rosenberg)  and is sometimes called “emergency empathy.”  This is used when you experience a person moving into an activated state.  To make an empathic connection to what’s alive in the person.  This is different than not intellectual understanding. In this you guess what the person may have heard or experienced,  such as “Are you feeling upset because your need your need for support is not being met?”  Your goal is to emotionally understand, not get more information or interrogate.  It is not about being right or wrong, only to really feel that their experience is honored.  

 

The pressure to speak quickly and/or perfectly is related more to our own "issues" (such as fear of rejection, need for acceptance, the pressure to perform) than the actual needs in a clinical situation!  Often our best work occurs when we release the pressure to perform, to achieve or to help.   

 

*a. Exercise:   What values do you hold that you anticipate or imagine may clash with the values of the patients or families in the hospital or parish setting? How might you respond to these comments?

  

"The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away."   Would the context change your response; for example, if this was said to a father whose son as just died?  

"People tell me that 'The Lord will never put more on you than you can bear."

"Why is God  doing this to my child?"

 

 

*b. Exercise: Take this comment and identify significant  deletions: "I did not like what happened at the meeting we had with the doctor last night.  He did not know what he was doing and my husband did not ask the right questions.”  

 

“Nobody else in the family cares about what was going on."  

 

Several phrases could represent hidden or protected information that questions might fill in missing facts or unacknowledged feelings.  What questions would you ask to prompt the person to speak about the deleted information?  

 

5.c. Questions to uncover distortions, which occur in internal belief systems or in the perception of external expectations or realities.  Common internal distortions include "I must be perfect, in control, consistent, strong and get everything right the first time."  Distortions can be seen in the myth of  "all or none" thinking.  All or none thinking becomes obvious when people use gross generalizations.  Such split views of the world and the self often include such terms as:  No one, never, always, forever, every time, nobody, everybody, everywhere.  These gross generalizations are sometimes spoken to capture the internal experience of the person speaking rather than to accurately represent the reality of the event.  One way to address them is simply to restating the generalization as a question; "No one? ..." BUT it may be easy to overuse this clarification, to be sarcastic or judgmental in challenging overstatements.  

 

Unrealistic expectations of self and other are often the source of disappointment, disillusionment and resentment.  Questioning distorted expectations can begin to address these difficult issues. 

 

* Exercise:  On a clinical unit where you have experienced the nurses are responsive and caring, a man that who you have worked with for several nights says: "The nurse's are terrible here.  None of them care about anyone."  What are some potential responses that might uncover the distortions without becoming defensive of the hospital yet get to the deeper issues?  

*How do you respond when someone criticizes such institutions as God, the medical center, the government, the church/faith institution, etc.?(Hint:  God and all the rest can take care of themselves.)

 

"Why" questions can be important intentional confrontations but, in this setting,  “why” questions tend to trigger defensiveness and confrontations.  

 

Many of us grew up with the use of the "why" question as a rhetorical accusation, i.e.  "why did you spill your milk all over the floor?"  I still can't think of a retort to that one!

 

6. Perception check: As a listener, you regularly check out the meanings, the feelings and the contents that are communicated by the speaker's facial expression, tone and quality of voice, rhythm of movement, body position, breathing, eye movements and much more.   From as early as two weeks of age, we are able to recognize and respond to the emotions that are communicated from the people that are important to us.   Sometimes a perception check will include an interpretation such as commenting on the obvious, but often ignored events, such as tears, some handicap or a painful obvious reality of tension in the room.   Some people are more skilled than others are reading non-verbal communication accurately.  It is a skill that can be honed, specifically in intentional group settings like process groups. 

 

In checking out perceptions, we are often using our own emotions as resource.  In a new or low trust relationship, it is helpful to tone down the emotional intensity of the word choice in order to decrease invasiveness, confrontation or threat.  There is less chance of rejection, or defensive denial and more willingness to share further when we inquire about someone's irritation vs. their rage!

 

Process comments are am important type of perception check.  This includes statements where you note the non-verbal parts of communicaton, such as tone, pace, facial expression, etc.  

 

* Exercise:  Discuss which emotions are the most comfortable and uncomfortable for you. Practice expressing the forbidden emotions in hospital scenarios.  The emotions on the chart at the end may stimulate some thoughts. (Savage, 1996. p. 52)  

 

One Formula to present a perception would be : 

stem + toned down emotional words + context + question

 

I get the impression that you were irritated (concerned, tense…vs. mad as hell) when the doctor came in the room and lifted your gown in front of your pastor.   Do you want to talk about what that was like for you?

 

* Exercise:

Susan, a 20 year old patient on your medical-surgical unit, says;  "The doctor just told me that I was 6 weeks pregnant."  While she is telling you this, her cheeks are pale, and she turns her head to look away from you.  Her breath is shallow.  Her hands are clasped.  Her tone is soft and a little raspy.  What do you think she is feeling?  How would you respond?

 

A 45 year old woman is telling you about a procedure that she will have tomorrow.  She stretches her neck and plays with her hands. Her breathing is shallow and quick.  The  skin on her upper lip is slightly shiny with tiny beads of sweat and her eyes seem to move quickly from one place to another, without looking at you directly. What might she be feeling and how might you respond?  

 

A child is staring at her IPAD and ignoring you, and you know she witnessed and intervened in a domestic violence attack.  What might she be feeling and how might you intervene?  

 

7. Responses to Criticism 

Everyone is sensitive to criticism. Our sensitivity may be a survival mechanism that relates to the danger of being cut off from social protection.  We experience pain and become injured when we hear or sense that we are not meeting expectations.  Sometimes historical touch points and internal unrealistic expectations exaggerate this defensive response.  When we hear criticism through the lenses of never living up to the demands of a parent, caregiver or teacher, we are often hyper sensitive to criticism.  This may look like “I don’t care what others think of me.”  Some people are so injured in the sensitivity of their early life that they have to cut themselves off completely from the need for others. Sometimes we are more critical of ourselves and others because of such experiences.  At some point all of us receive criticism and fall short of the ideals that we have and that others have for us.  The more compassionate we are with ourselves about our human limitations, the more open we can be to the criticism of others.      

 

We have to learn to deal with the potentially inflammatory moment when someone confronts, criticizes or even condemns us in clinical situations.  Our automatic response is often defense, justification or submission, but these rarely contribute to communication. Usually we need to slow down, take a deep breath and try to pay attention to our own internal responses without over reacting.   Often we initially rehash the content or facts in order to convince the perceived attacker of our innocence.  This may be a good place to start but rarely works.  Instead we have to find ways to get out of the content and back to the process of what occurred.  

 

We will spend another entire presentation on conflict management and negotiation. For now we will discuss one way to get back to the process and to deal with criticism is by agreeing with any statement that is true for us, contains some truth, or contains a generalization that is sometimes true for us.  People need validation and acknowledgement before they can enter into fruitful discussion or let down their defenses enough to admit their own part of a conflict.  This way of dealing with criticism is effective when the internal experience of the listener is genuine humility and acceptance of human fragility, rather than subterfuge or defense.  

 

Here are a few examples of this sophisticated technique:  

 

That's right, 

You're probably right, 

That's probably true, 

I guess you're right

I did that

 

However, it is important to agree with only what is true for you, without a sense of resignation or victimization.  This skill, called "fogging", needs to be coupled with productive questions, perceptions checks, reframing, paraphrasing, etc.   

 

Also it’s important to allow the impact of the criticism to be apparent at an appropriate level.  People need to know they can impact you without overwhelming you; if you feel overwhelmed with a criticism, that is an issue for you to get perspective on to be a professional chaplain.  The balance is to be impacted, communicate the impact of only THIS criticism, not the whole history of all the criticism you’ve ever received  - a complex skill! 

 

*Exercise:  With a partner, talk about a recent criticism that you experienced or heard about.  Generate an initial authentic response that represents agreement. 

 

8. Criticism follow up includes the questions that coaches the critic to be specific about what behaviors and what context stimulates the criticism.   This means getting the speaker to give missing information from the narrative.  The difficult part of such questioning is to genuinely want the information and not use the questioning to blame,  interrogate or turn the fire on the critic.  When the speaker feels s/he has to justify himself, herself or the criticism, the follow up becomes an attack.   

 

*Exercises:  Discuss some responses to deal with these criticisms:

 

You haven't done anything since you came to see me.   I need somebody who is a Bible believing Christian, who can tell me what God wants me to do right now.

 

You did not come back to see me yesterday.  I don't think you are as responsible as a minister should be. 

 

You can’t help me because you are Christian (Jewish, Hindu, etc.) and I am not. 

 

You are just like all the rest of the people in this hospital.  All you care about is my money.

 

*Exercise:  Perhaps you have a few specific criticisms in mind about which you are particularly concerned.  How would you deal with them? 

 

9. Behavior description is a way to reflect back to the person a description of their actual quantifiable behavior without judgment or accusation which is much more difficult than it seems.  This is the first stage of “non violent communication.”  Instead of making an assumption about an interpretation of a behavioral response, this allows the listener to identify what she or he has experienced, saw, observed without interpretation or personalization.  The description invites the speaker to clarify and become aware of the impact of certain nonverbal characteristics.  

 

I have noticed that you have not responded to my questions about your family.  

 

You have been rubbing your hands for the last few minutes. 

 

You became quiet when I asked you about your church membership.  

 

10. *Providing supportive comments. These comments include expressions of reassurance, agreement, praise, encouragement, acceptance, comfort, affirmation, consolation, reassurance of positive qualities, reassurance about circumstances, and expressions of concern.   Supportive comments are important ways to express care and nurture.  HOWEVER, premature supportive comments can be distracting.  They come out of the listener's anxiety or defensiveness.  Sometimes chaplains and helping professionals tend to move too quickly to rescue people (and themselves) from painful expressions and experiences.  Paradoxically premature reassurance serves to confirm that the pain is overwhelming, intolerable or bad.  The strong non-verbal message is that we cannot handle staying in the pain.   

 

We can support and affirm someone without agreeing with them.   Sometimes providing support is confused with expressing agreement with the content of a statement. 

 

* Exercise: Think of statements or situations where you have or would provide immediate reassurance out of anxiety or out of not knowing anything else to do.  How could you explore the comment before the reassurance?    Think of a way to support and affirm someone with whom you disagree, perhaps someone who is complaining about the nursing staff on a clinical unit where you have experienced kind and competent nursing care or someone who is expressing a view of God that is offensive to you. 

 

11. *Offering concrete help, intervening, some types of teaching, This includes environmental manipulation, active interventions and physical protection.  Examples of concrete help may include: referrals to other disciplines, enlisting or encouraging others to help, phone calls, transportation, offering tissue or water, religious rituals, prayers, communion, relaxation training, hypnosis, and music therapy and other physical interventions.  Actual concrete help communicates care, concern and investment in the person.  However, this is another area where the caregiver's anxiety may stimulate over-functioning.  We may move to do something because we don't know how to be with someone who feels so helpless and overwhelmed.  Spiritual care involves assessing when to remain with the pain and when to try to alleviate the pain.  Pain is often part of healing. 

 

Physical pain provides a particularly difficult challenge in terms of Spiritual assistance.  We are part of the team to address this challenge. Some concrete interventions that we can offer if we learn them are guided meditation, breathing exercises, comforting prayer, silent support, music and healing touch.   

 

12. *Offering Prescriptions: includes giving advice, giving direction, solving problems, offering suggestions, giving invitations, giving guidance, educating, providing information, problem solving, providing reality orientation, and normalizing the situation.  Also offering prescriptions may include making referrals to other professionals.

 

Prescriptions can be good, yet they are an often overused intervention.  Advice can come more out of the anxiety or helplessness of the caregiver than out of the genuine need of the client.   Ordering, warning, threatening or moralizing are prescriptions that are rarely helpful since they take away the autonomy of the person and lead to an over/under type of relationship.  

 

What is difficult? To know oneself. What is easy? To give advice. 

Thales of Miletus when asked for advice.

 

13. *Redirecting the conversation from one area to another.  Changing the direction of the conversation can be a purposeful, conscious or intuitive choice to pursue another avenue or to return to a chosen focus in light of limited time.  Without the element of assessment and choice, redirection can indicate an unconscious reaction to anxiety or fear in the listener.  Inexperienced chaplains often redirect the conversation away from more painful, awkward or confusing information or topics to safer areas for their own comfort - and they are largely unaware of the diversion.   Distraction, withdrawal or avoidance of material serves as a way to allay the listener's anxiety about a topic or about the response of the speaker.   The speaker will “protect” themselves and the listener by noticing the avoidance and keeping the conversation in safe territory.    

 

*Exercise:  We all have areas of conversation that are uncomfortable to discuss.  Name a few of these areas for yourself and how you might track someone in conversation that is addressing these areas.  For example, how do you deal with sexuality in conversations with patients, families or staff?  

 

14. Summarizing content or process of an interaction so that the person overhears an overview of what has been experienced.  Such a summary can lead to reconsideration, correction, elaboration, etc by the speaker.  The speaker may be come more aware of how attentive the chaplain is to their words and their life, which may increase feels of being important or worthwhile.  The summary can be accompanied by some response, such as an assessment, a judgement, or a reflection that the listener has to the material or the person

 

"You have shared about your prayer life and you concerns about surgery today."

"It sounds like what you are most concerned about is..."  (This is both an assessment, "most concerned" and a summary)

"Your stories about your relationship with your daughter let me overhear your deep love for her.  I was touched by the tenderness of the relationship.  Your greatest concern at this time seems to be about her future in light of your own illness.  Your care and concern for her move me.  I wonder if it would be helpful to speak further about specific concerns that you have."   

"You provided so much comfort to one another through your caress and your tears together."

 

Initiating Touch:  Touch is on the borderline between basic and advanced skills.   Touch can be a great communicator of concern and solidarity.  We offer comfort through touch, intuitively knowing the boundary between appropriate and inappropriate, between comfortable and uncomfortable, between helpful and destructive.  However touch can be a powerful and destructive force.  Inappropriate or uncomfortable touch can be a violation, particularly when there is a power differential.  So we are required to examine our use of touch carefully.  Each person has a history with touch, a different toleration and acceptance of touch; plus touch is highly influenced by cultural and situational influences. 

 

What are your habits concerning touch in Spiritual situations?   

 

 When someone shares their pain or problems with you, these are  10 Non-Empathic Responses that you usually want to avoid

 

Advice: "Here's what you should do..." "Have you thought about..."

 

One-upping: "That's it? Just last week guess what happened to me..."

 

Educating: "This could be a great opportunity to grow from this is you would just..."

 

Consoling: "It will be ok, don't worry. Things will work out.."

 

Story-telling: "My friend just went through this, you see what happened was..."

 

Shutting Down: "You really shouldn't be feeling this way, you're being unreasonable..."

 

Sympathizing: "You poor thing! That is just terrible how you're being mistreated!"

 

Interrogating: "Are you sure something didn't happen to him? When's the last time..."

 

Explaining: "Look, there was something that came up at work and it had to get done, that why..."

 

Correcting: "You don't really have your facts straight, see what actually happened was..." 

 

 

Non violent communication includes making observations, talking about feelings, needs and making requests that can be accepted or denied without any force or judgement.  This is a complex and wonderful way of communicating which we will cover more extensively. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

III: Professional Practice Skills Competencies

 

What are indicators of “effective spiritual support” and “well-being” from your perspective? How do you assess them? Using examples, demonstrate the skills, strategies, and interventions you use to notice what is effective in terms of spiritual support and what do you say, do, embody that you believe fosters well-being with care-recipients, their families, and staff? 

 

 

So many books have informed me on these reflections. If there is a concept about which you want more information, email me and I’ll make a recommendation. 

 

 

 

 

Back