When someone tells me they feel a “call to ministry” or a desire to go into religious service in any tradition, they often seek is a simple and sweet confirmation rather than an exploration.
What was most helpful to me in my discernment were the people who said: “if you can do anything else do it” and who explored my complex motivations.
My thesis is that the still small voice of God is often more complicated and multifaceted than as we are taught to believe.
The experience of a call into the religious life is a mystery and a challenge. How do we explore and examine a religious "call" deeply, perhaps critically without undermining or underestimating the mystery of God? Carefully. We look at the "call" like a precious gem from various angles, trying to see the lights and darks of the mysterious process of moving towards a vocation related to God.
Perhaps your call is related to your understanding of yourself as someone who listens to people who are hurting, in pain, in need. You find a deep joy in being a source of help. Maybe you love being in or leading worship or feel most alive when you are in prayer. Maybe the study of Scripture excites you and you want to share your passion with others. You may have felt a tiny tug to explore ministry which you know you have ignored, because such a grand call is inconvenient or unbelievable. You may ask “Who am I to be called by God,” and doubt this pull towards more investment in religious service. Perhaps you are called to service as an active lay person and question the importance of that call.
On the other hand, maybe you pursued a religious calling, such as through ordination, or other religious recognition, then left the ministry for complex reasons. You ask how this mystery of call which was strong can fade or end, sometimes, leaving a residue of pain, confusion, discouragement, regret or anger. Perhaps you served for a time, and left because the work was not what you thought it was going to be. Perhaps you found your path blocked or, through some difficulty with a congregation or a denomination, you lost a crucial piece of the sense of call over time. You may have experienced abandonment or betrayal when your tradition did not encourage or support your sense of call, or maybe you grew out of your call. Maybe the whole concept of call is a conundrum to you. You feel skeptical about the call that other people describe and wonder what it all means.
An exploration of the less noble and more internal unconscious dynamics behind the acknowledged motivations towards call does not have to contaminate the mystery. These motivations are often overlooked in the discernment process about the call to ministry or mitzvah, as well as other helping professions. We fear that if we acknowledge the negative, we are negating the positive. We can wonder if the call is less valid when we find undercurrents, pressures, or “selfish” motives from our personal history. Yet, these forces contribute to the call and to the choice of vocation for everyone. When they are acknowledged alongside the more overt and noble motivations, we are more integrated and our energy is more available for service. The call to leave a religious vocation can be a sign of health. The call away from ministry, mitzvah, religious service does not have to framed as an embarrassing failure or a mistake. Likewise, the call to religious life which may originally come from our pathology can effect goodness, justice and mercy. We can uncover our sun and our shadow motivations, giving us ways to use both more fully.
When we don't acknowledge these mixed motives, we often undermine our best intentions. These mixed motives, when unacknowledged leak out in anger, anxiety, depression, overwork and various types of misbehavior.
The call we feel (which may be recognized or unrecognized by others) includes the whispers from our unknown selves, the residues of our past wounds and the influences from unexamined sources. When we can face the complexity of “vocation” we can serve more fully and more effectively, though sometimes we may be more uncomfortable at the beginning. With awareness, we can make lifegiving decisions about call, ordination and paid or unpaid religious service. Instead of relying only on others or on our inner voice to discern whether our call is valid, we can enter into self examination. We may find a renewed energy for our religious calling or find that we have a call to some vocation that is less traditionally religious. We may chose to leave the tradition of our youth and find a home in another tradition; we may re invest in the rituals of our youth with renewed enthusiasm.
In this article, I have a more general exploration of vocation in the appendix which includes a reflection about divine revelation and the gifts of the Spirit, as well as the dynamics about how a community confirms or discourages our call. I will end with the unconscious motivations that are often pushed under the rug of the congregation.
The process of religious call contains conscious and unconscious, individual and communal, emotional, spiritual and rational influences. There are influences from our early history which we sometimes deny, forget or ignore. Under the guise of passive language of “I have been called by God” we propose that all the impetus and motivation was outside of our will or choice. Yet our decisions are often more influenced by the unconscious than we realize or than we admit. If you doubt that reality, read some of the newest literature on the topic, such as the popular book, “Blink.”
There are no pure calls and responses. With reflection we become aware of how personal history, personality structure and cultural influences are active in our choices. These mixed motives do not validate or invalidate the call religiously or theologically. In fact our call is more powerful for our courage to examine ourselves. Our call can become more clear, more passionate and more helpful to others through the process of self examination.
The experience of satisfaction with career choice involves expectation. If the choosing person is unaware of or in denial about the complexity of their motivations, their possibility of dissatisfaction and burnout increases. Also others may be misused out of the unconscious person’s mixed motives. The exercise of examining oneself for the conflicting motivations and exploring the personal needs that are being met by a call serves to assist the person in their formation for ministry.
In order to explore unconscious calls to ministry, we need to acknowledge that personal history influences vocational desires and decisions.
I am building on the work from the 1972 article “FAMILY PATTERNS, UNCONSCIOUS MOTIVATION AND THE CALL TO THE RELIGIOUS LIFE” Donald S. Williamson explored eight "patterns of unconscious motivation" related to the religious call. This is a work in progress which I revise as new thoughts arise.
Williamson described eight patterns of unconscious motivation which present in "combinations and with varying degrees of intensity within the life of any given individual." I have expanded his original selection using my own interpretation of the Enneagram. These motivations may be in a variety of combinations and intensities.
1.The call may be influenced by a strong desire to perform, achieve, please,, comply with or sooth the people who we admired or admire. These are the identified treasured authorities, including family or community. “I always knew you would be the minister in our family.” Some people describe being “dedicated to God” even before birth or through some significant trauma for the caregivers where they were promised to God. This can be thrilling and a source of esteem but the pressure can eclipses the person’s own sense of self. (Enneagram 3)
2. The call may be influenced by a strong desire to be special, to differentiate, separate perhaps even provoke your family. Some people state that they are nothing like their family and chose this way to reject them in a very “nice way.” Enneagram 4:
3. The call may be influenced by a strong desire to seek love, warmth, to help others in order to compensate for early deficits, deprivation or abandonment. This motivation often leads to unrealistically high expectations and disappointment. Enneagram 2
With this need and unconscious desire the person may find it very hard to “give of himself” in his work as a minister. Like everyone else, he will replay the primary family drama in every important social drama in which he is an actor. Since his early family experience has been unusually conflicted, the re-enactment of it is tempted to follow the script. It may be difficult for him to work with those who have authority over him. It will be a struggle to relate to those perceived as cold, distant, or manipulative. Some important people in the community may be experienced as rejecting of him or unresponsive to his ministry. Others seem to be trying to control him or take away his freedom.
This person "unconsciously identifies those who represent father, mother, brothers and sisters within the religious community so he relives the primary family drama hoping that there will be a better epilog this time around. But his ways of relating to people can be so rigid and his way of perceiving people so distorted that this is unlikely to happen. Then he begins to wonder why he is in a religious vocation and wishes to be anywhere else on earth.
This call to ministry becomes the only way "to handle difficult personal problems" by trying to help others solve theirs. The problems come when the person's own situation "immobilizes pastoral ministry" or "breaks through in an overwhelming way in his own self-consciousness."
4. The call may be influenced by a strong desire to fulfill a duty or responsibility and to cope with or to make amends for intense guilt, inadequacy or shame feelings. These feelings may be related to the norms of their family or community. Everyone has normal sexual and aggressive impulses. These impulses may be thwarted or shamed in some contexts. In order to protect the sense of self worth, the person may use the external boundaries of the called position to attempt to protect themselves from themselves. Some children respond to a hostile and unresponsive world by feeling guilty for existing. (Enneagram 6)
The religious calling may be a way to make up for bad thoughts, feelings or behaviors. If the child was punished for normal exploration of her body, she may
Religious life may be a type of penance. This calling predisposes the minister to overwork in an effort to unconsciously save themselves.
Another face of this call may be the desire to compensate for low self esteem and chronic worthlessness. The face of this call may look like the need to be special, to be set apart, and even set above to relieve the fears that the person would never gain importance in other ways.
The relief of "being identified with God, the angels and heaven, and with a world-wide community which has a unique tradition, history and faith" will not be enough. Instead the hollowness may be expressed in the abuse of power when threatened. This motivation can create vindictive patterns which remind those around the person of the role's power and prestige.
Related to coping, religious life may be seen as a way to control and handle aggressive, destructive and sexual drives or feelings. There is the illusion of a community, a structure and a life that focuses on love, gentleness, and turning the other cheek which will force the person to forgo these impulses.
Some families do not bless assertive, competitive, sexual or angry feelings. Therefore handling these feelings, impulses and desires may become so uncomfortable that the person desires a profession "safe" from these discomforts.
This person avoids the anxiety about intense feelings by using "religious life as a way of controlling or avoiding the full implications of their own sexuality" and power,
"People are often willing to use the symbols of religion to support the inhibition of emotional life in general and aggressive and sexual feelings in particular." The tragedy of is that repression of these energy generating experiences creates dissociation from deeper feelings, depression, depletion and burn out.
- The call may be influenced by a strong desire to enjoy life, to have fun, to play and expend the self for others. This person does well with the joy of service and may struggle to be present with the pain and suffering. They may avoid some parts of ministry and eventually be seen as unreliable. ( Enneagram 7)
- The call may be influenced by a strong desire to make peace and to harmonize the fights and conflict of the world. When there are periods where there is no harmony, they may withdraw or become overly solicitous which can take a toll on their health and on the growth of the congregation and it’s members. (Enneagram 9)
7. The call may be influenced by a strong desire to be “the Hero”, the mediator or the "distracter,” from a strong pressure to save the family of origin. Often these roles are most energized in families where there are addictions or mental health problems, such as severe depression, Bi-polar illness and Obsessive Compulsive disorder. The person who is driven by identification with a role feels most alive when she or he is over-functioning to help others or the world often at a high personal cost. As long as they feel needed, essential they are protected from the unconscious fear is that they are useless or the world is chaotic. Enneagram 8
This call may be influenced by a strong desire to be in control, strong and powerful. This may be related to the role of the parentified or the perfect child role. The scapegoat role is when someone carries the distress of their family system. They are framed as the problem and then the system does not have to look at itself too closely. The perfect or parentified child is the swing role that carries the ideals, values and hopes for the system. This child is so good, so helpful or talented, or exceptional that they carry the hope for the family or system. This expectation is carried into the call to be special, to be set apart as a leader. There is little room in the system for the person to get off the moving pedestal of expectations. The illusion can be that there is so far to fall. Enneagram 1
When any of these become an over identification with a false role, the person sacrifices authenticity, autonomy and self-hood. Eventually there will be resentment and the “sacrifice” may be framed as made for noble or righteous reasons. There is little room to question the pressures and distortions of the call.
- The call may be influenced by a strong desire to develop and teach a philosophical world-view to help make sense of violence, disease and personal tragedy. This person may remain in their head and in charge of controlling people’s righteousness. The necessary messiness of hurting people may be a challenge.
Each of of these personality preferences brings a strength that could be used on behalf of the faith community. Each personality preference may also be a source of dysfunction in terms of overfunctioning or underfunctioning on behalf of others.
CONCLUSION
The call to the religious life is complex. We interpret the complex constellation of processes and experiences which tell our story many times over our lifetime.
In any vocational decision both personal history and related unconscious factors are operating. When the unconscious motivation remains in conflict with the conscious feelings and desires of the person, there is a high cost and potential danger. Bad choices can be interpreted as the working of the Holy Spirit and people can be hurt.
The motivations underneath our decisions are complex and rich, just as are those we serve. As we become increasing aware of ourselves we can serve more fully and experience life more abundantly. With reflection we can develop a deeper understanding of ourselves and we can learn to use ourselves more accurately and effectively in the service of God and others.