Early Childhood through Object Relations Family Systems Theory
Editorial and content feedback welcome:
I invite you to read this material about early childhood in a reflective way.
Allow yourself to think about how your early life was similar or different from each example. Where your memories are incomplete, imagine what you may have experienced based on what you know from later events. You can construct a working model from the information that you have. You have information about your caregivers from your own experience. You can play with various assumptions about what might have occurred. As you explore your own experience, you are developing self awareness that will serve you in your relationships, both personally and professionally.
Try to imagine and to emotionally visit with compassion your own experience as a young child. This can occur more readily if you stop frequently to let the information soak in. If this becomes too painful, use your journal to express some of the feelings. You are not your feelings. However your feelings are important resources. You may find that some of the work is too painful or difficult to continue by yourself. Therapy is essential to your own good work.
One common response is to deny any problems, to make excuses or to justify the primary caregivers who created pain in your life. Another response is to condemn them. Another is to identify with your own children and punish yourself for your failures. Part of the process of healing is facing the reality of human limitations, which will include anger and disappointment, fear and disorientation, compassion and acceptance. Try not to protect or condemn your parents or caregivers any longer. They did the best they could with what they had at the time. Some failures were inevitable. Some failures were preventable. Examine and limit the blame or shame about your own parenting or caregiving. Turn the energy of blaming into the work to use your resources, positive memories, journaling, mentors, to face some of the painful parts of reality.
As we discussed before, the importance of the caregiver’s context, the larger “holding” environment", is important. People learn the majority of their skills for parenting and child development through the memories, stories, advice and encouragement of their community, especially the family that provided basic caregiving. Without a functional community that is both supportive, flexible, financially stable and knowledgeable, the caregivers and the children suffer.
Early development from 2-18 months
II. From 2-3 months to 6 months:
Mahler’s "Symbiosis."
Stern’s "The Sense of the Core Self."
Daniel Stern proposes that the infant has awareness of self and other from birth. About the age of 2-3 months, the infant is obviously more sensitive to the outside world. The infant begins to smile at faces, to coo and to respond to sights and sounds. The infant is aware of and responding to the physical communication from the caregiver in a variety of ways. The infant senses the physical warmth of the body as well as the emotional comfort or anxiety associated with the mother or primary caregiver.
The physical and emotional “holding” of the (m)other is crucially important to the helpless infant during this period of increasing awareness and sensitivity. The "centered holding" that we discussed in the last presentation is very important. The actions of cradling, feeding, changing and other ways of responding to the infant provide for more than just the physical needs. These encounters allow the helpless infant to borrow, to catch, to experience at a deep bodily level the (m)other's security and power. By borrowing the (m)other's security, the infant is able to experience an important measure of control, perhaps even an experience of omnipotence.
With optimal holding the infant may even feel all powerful. This "illusion" of being all powerful provides the infant with the foundation for the very important initial trust and confidence in the environment. D.W. Winnecott and others proposed the idea that the stable sense of omnipotence in infancy creates the foundation of a solid sense of self and positive development. This omnipotence becomes even more pronounced during the later phase of 18 months- 36 months, the stage of “practicing.”
How does the infant experience omnipotence in the midst of such powerlessness? First, we have to look at the need of the infant for various responses from the parent. At various times, the infant needs to be soothed, to be stimulated and to left alone. The alternation of responses needs to match the infant's temperament and current state of being. Under suitable conditions, the infant gazes at a face that is usually responsive to the infant's moods, needs and temperament. The infant has an innate capacity to respond to the eye-to-eye contact with a human face, especially when the face is in vertical motion and smiling. In this way, the infant is wired to respond to signals from the caregivers of love and nurture, smiles and nodding. Under suitable condition, when the infant is tired or upset, the face is comforting. When the infant is content, the face is calm. When the infant is happy, the face mirrors and may even accentuate that happiness.
The accurate is evident as the (m)other acknowledges the infant's subtle ways of communicating. For example when the infant wants less stimulation the infant will turn the head and gaze in another direction. The (m)other who is attuned will allow the infant psychological rest and space by not "chasing" the infant's gaze. The (m)other uses the signals to tailor her responses to the infant's needs. The parent, often intuitively, imitates some of the infant’s facial expressions, verbalizations and movements in ways that are soothing; cooing, nodding and rocking to infant into sleep or quiet.
The parent's responsiveness is communicated from the parent's whole body, not just with the face. Messages are sent and received as the infant is rocked, spoken to, kept warm, played with, changed and fed. These various types of engagement provide a physical and social response which uses all the senses. This is where we begin to see that the infant may move between feeling all powerful and all powerless. The infant’s discomfort, distress and delight are not confined by time and space. First we will address the comfort, then we will look at the distress.
The comfort, when it arrives, appears to be all that there is, all encompassing. The infant is not simply fed, but is held close to the body smelling, seeing and experiencing the fulfillment of complete satisfaction. The infant molds closely to the body of the caregiver with the infant's whole body so that the soothing is all that there is in the world, giving the impression of complete satisfaction. Optimally the physical soothing alternates with the face to face eye contact which is essential to the healthy bonding of the mother and infant. The parent notices the infant's non-verbal posture, gaze, and verbal responses, then attempts to regulate her own needs so the infant's needs are met. This is unconditional, sacrificial love, which is a birthright of infants.
The infant borrows the structure and soothing of the primary caregiver to organize the infant's chaotic world. The fragile infant borrows the calm soothing and the schedule of the mother to provide stability to the world. This structure is both emotional and physical. The physical structure is as concrete as gently creating and adhering to a schedule that is tailored to this particular infant. Such a schedule can be as simple as having regular times of feeding and sleeping, which allows the infant to begin to predict the patterns of the day. The caregiver reads the infant's cues about needs and creates a flexible schedule through some trial and error.
The responsive caregiver (who has his or her own functional contextual holding environment) is able to provide for the healthy alternation of frustration and gratification. The infant has basic needs, such as hunger, that create agitation, discomfort and fear. A strong sense of trust and bonding can be established out of having basic needs met in a consistent and loving fashion. When the baby is wet, she is changed. When she is hungry, she is fed. When she is scared, she is comforted. The response is brisk and accurate to the need, so the infant does not become overwhelmed. The infant comes to expect and anticipate that basic needs will be met; the world is a trustworthy, caring place to be.
Frustration, pain and separation always occur. The (m)other will fail at times. The infant will be inconsolable, with bodily pain that cannot be relieved. However, with a fairly predictable relief schedule, the infant comes to expect relief from tensions and pain. The infant learns to live with a sense of "confident expectation" as a part of healthy bonding. This confident expectation enables the infant to wait for satisfaction without undue panic. This capacity to modify and adjust to the experience of tension is a very important part of human development that the person will use throughout life.
This confident expectation is part of a "self soothing" mechanism. Self soothing is an important part of the beginning of the consciousness and strength of character in the self, what is sometimes called the "ego." This aspect of character provides the ability to delay gratification.
With the (m)other's soothing presence and loving investment, the infant is able to give love to herself, to emotionally invest positive feelings in her own representation of the self. This self love and trust of the other decreases the terror that occurs when the caregiver is not able to immediately relieve the agitation. The growing child or adult takes inside herself various "self soothing mechanisms," such as confident expectation and positive self investment. These mechanisms decrease the tension, anxiety and need for self protection. Therefore, the person has more energy for other pursuits and less of the generalized terror that I will describe later.
With self soothing and with longer periods of uninterrupted calm attention, the person experiences the space to reflect and to contemplate themselves, their world and the experience with others. The infant is given the time to be with herself without having to respond to inner needs or outer demands. This creates the beginnings of internal awareness as pleasant and acceptable.
The experience of emotional and physical pain for the infant
Whereas once people believed that infants did not experience "real pain", now there is strong research that suggests infant's experience very intense pain. The emotional and physical pain of the infant is large and intense, global in proportion. Many of the ways that adults have to decrease pain are not available to the infant. As adults when we are in pain we can remember times when we had pain that got better. We can create some story to explain the pain, to figure the pain out in order to sooth our fears. We can distract ourselves, redirect our attention or deny the pain.
The infant has no memory, no story to organize experience and provide comfort. Unlike an adult, the infant cannot use past experience to predict when the pain will end. He cannot use rational thought to understand what the pain is about. He cannot use distraction or various defenses to ignore the pain. Without these adult capacities, the infant’s horror must be overwhelming. Frustration and pain do not have a foreseeable end and must seem limitless, monstrous and futile. The intensity of the infant’s experience may be incomprehensible to adults. This kind of agony would be intolerable. The overwhelming terror and pain of the infant when the basic needs are not met for various reasons cannot be tolerated.
On top of this, the pain is extended even beyond the boundaries of the self. As we addressed in the last section there are times in early development when the child appears to feel a sense of merger with the primary caregiver. The boundaries that we acknowledge as adults are not as developed. The infant has some idea that the caregiver is one with the infant. The infant cannot differentiate clearly the boundaries between the infant and the mother, the motherinfant and the world, the inside and the outside.
Because of these fuzzy boundaries, the infant probably experiences something close to hatred for the (m)other when the (m)other does not provide pain relief or gratification of needs. This hatred may sound far fetched and threatening because this hatred is scary for us to consider, even as adults.
The literature and my clinical experience with adults abused as children overcame my own initial skepticism about this hatred. When we realize the magnitude of the infant's pain, it is more easy to see that such pain and hatred could instinctually generate fear, even terror. The fear is that something will destroy the caregiver (which endangers the infant) or that the caregiver could destroy the infant. With so many infants and adults, I have seen the fear of being abandoned or killed by an inadequate caregiver held in an uneasy tension with the need to protect that caregiver. We must remember that no matter what the infant's existence depends on this person. The tension of unmet needs and the fear tend to compound one another.
This gives us a picture of the suffering that infants experience. The infant must defend against such intense experiences of deprivation. In the midst of the overwhelming experiences of frustration and deprivation, the infant begins to use psychological defense mechanisms. These defense mechanisms are patterns of thought and behavior that protect some essential part of the person. The infant learns that if no one will protect her, then she will protect herself. We will study several patterns of defense, including “splitting” and “projective identification”, which serve to protect the infant. These protective patterns are present in everyone, but become more exaggerated and disruptive as the infant must use them for basic survival. These psychological defenses are part of the psychological equipment which are necessary to protect the infant from the intolerable pain.
Splitting
Splitting: When the feelings of the infant or the relating patterns of the external object of attachment are too painful, too frustrating, for the fragile infant to handle, they are split. The split is into the polarities of satisfying or frustrating; the most frustration aspects are repressed. Therefore the good or satisfying parts are protected and kept in consciousness. Part of this splitting is biological as the two sides of the brain are not connected until the infant is about 3-4 months old. The complete connection of the two sides of the brain does not occur until adolescence.
A split into a good mother/father and a bad mother/father is created when the infant has intense needs that are not being met. When the “failures” by the caregiver occur, the baby cannot tolerate the pain that has been mentioned earlier. So the bad mother and the good mother are split, just as the good self and the bad self are split. Winnicott saw this separation in service of higher union, not distance from the mother. Later in the development, the child experience higher needs as not being met, such as the need for self expression. The child begins to realize that some feelings, responses and behaviors are unacceptable in a particular society or culture. In adolescence the pre-verbal splitting becomes reactivated. The child wants to express parts of the self that are not allowed. Splitting occurs in the image of the child's self and in the caregiver to ward off the intolerable experiences of shame and disgrace.
The splitting creates simpler, dualistic representations which can be “projected” out--placed outside of the safe orbit of the good me and good mother. The simpler representation can also be “introjected”--put inside--to be dealt with in a less threatening way. These split and repressed parts of the self are created to "get rid of ways of relating that are too painful to be borne in the central and conscious ego." This is the early source of a dualistic world view where the forces of good and evil are seen in conflict. Memory traces of good and bad are beginning to be laid down. This stage may be revisited at the time of courtship or in an intense religious experience where people feel a sense of complete merger, omnipotence and enthrallment. Such merger can be a sign of either health or disease. We will explore splitting in more depth in a later chapter.
An application of theory: “Repeat Offenders”
The understandings from early childhood can be important in our clinical work. The capacity to delay gratification through confident expectation, the investment of positive feelings into the representation of the self and splitting are evident when we encounter people who exhibit the tendency to get into some type of trouble repetitively. This would include "repeat offenders" or it might be visible in our own behavior.
The infant who experiences neglect, abuse or inconsistent responses to her neediness has long periods of helpless agony. When the infant’s basic needs are not met in a timely fashion, she does not learn to expect any consistent relief from her suffering. Remember back to the intense needs of the very young infant, when the parents must live from minute to minute as they work to assist the infant to regulate and stabilize such mundane tasks as eating and sleeping at regular intervals. The structure that the parents offer is so important for the newborn. Instead, some infants are not given the resources to learn to regulate themselves. They have to focus their energies to learn various patterns of survival and need gratification. If food or other nourishment is inconsistently available, it makes good survival sense to grab, to hord and to do whatever it takes to get whatever nourishment is offered, whenever it becomes available. Early survival may depend on such aggressive self promotion or covert manipulation, even for a young infant. When satisfaction or nourishment occurs, the self and the environment are all good. The infant cannot hold in her mind the memory of the overwhelming pain; it is too much to bear. So the events of gratification, of being warm, or dry or full become ideal. When gratification or satisfaction is delayed, the anxiety is intolerable since the experience of deprivation, and indeed the whole self, moves towards the "all bad." The "all bad" experience presents an intense, intolerable motivation to quickly jump into anything that will end the pain, including fantasy or gratification. For the adult, this creates an urgency that is gratified in any type of "self medication" through drugs, alcohol or sex.
Without adequate attunement, the infant does not develop confident expectation. Without this confidence, the infant does not learn to trust, to delay gratification or to develop a genuine love of self or the other. The infant, and later the adult, is unable to take inside herself, to internalize, the positive feelings for the self or the other that occur with need gratification during developmental dependency. During the "all bad" experience, the self is also all bad, which is the definition of shame. However, some people may not subjectively feel bad because they become detached and distant from the overwhelming experiences of pain. They disassociate to protect themselves from pain. Sometimes this occurs through cognitive vigilance or through some form of acting out their unconscious emotions. Without the internal structures that are part of positive self esteem and the confident expectation of gratification, the person cannot modulate or contain her own affect or experience. Without the internal structures that are given by self soothing, the person cannot slow down and reason with the intensity of their response. The person experiences a great deal of urgency or panic to respond , strongly and quickly to the shame and the “all bad” experience. The urgency interferes with the need to reflect or contemplate the experience. There are many ways to respond that do not serve the person well. Four ways to respond to the feeling of being all bad are: to attack self, to attack others, to avoid or to withdraw. Because of this reaction, the person may have great difficulty saving money, abstaining from sex or drugs, doing unpleasant work in the expectation of future gain or forgoing the immediate pleasure of revenge or aggression.
Many people have not experienced caregiving that created a sense of confident expectation and have lost touch with their inner lives. Pediatricians and other authorities during the 1900's often discouraged parents from comforting children "too much" because it was believed that too much holding would "spoil" the child and lead the child to be "selfish". There has been generous research that disproved these errors but some people still carry these fears into caregiving of young children. Some biblical passages and religious literature continues to be used to support various levels of physical and emotional abuse of children. Some children have nobody to provide the basic elements of safety, nutrition and nurturing These children have the potential to be involved in the crimes committed children that have been in the paper so much in the last year. These children never learned to feel connection or emotion for other human beings.
As Alice Miller says about the child that is abused: "They have all developed the art of not experiencing feelings, for a child can only experience his feelings when there is somebody there who accepts him fully, understands and supports him. If that is missing, if the child must risk losing the mother's love, or that of her substitute, then he cannot experience these feelings secretly 'just for himself' but fails to experience them at all. But nevertheless...something remains." The legacy of these early caregiving failures haunt the person and the society.
Each of us lives with some deprivation. We see the deprivation in ourselves and in the hospital, clinical or church setting. We see evidence of deprivation when we cannot delay gratification, when we cannot sooth ourselves and when we cannot connect with others. We have not learned to experience our own feelings just for ourselves. An understanding of this development can enhance our empathy while we set clear limits with people express impulsive, destructive behavior. Abuse and neglect are not an excuse for destructive behavior. Instead when we understand abuse and neglect, in our history and in the history of others, we are called to empathize not excuse.
There is hope. What is most remarkable is that about 50% of children who are abused still learn to function. Many abused children develop extraordinary amounts of compassion and maturity. The infant and child may have positive experiences with people, or God, or organizations like church and synagogue. Some children are able to use experiences with pets, nature even with stuffed toys to find a source of comfort, stability and strength. Both the degree of abuse and these experiences influence the level and degree of disruption and defensive patterns that occur.
Throughout life there are multiple opportunities for dependency to occur that is met with consistent, reliable and steady relationships. Dependency is not bad, as it is so often painted in our society. Dependency, even experiences of being out of control or helpless, can provide the context where healing can occur, especially for the young child. The child can move forward in the lifelong process of integration and rebirth. Different experiences can occur that revise the maps of reality laid down during infancy. Hospitalization, illness, trauma and normal developmental challenges like childbearing are just a few of the opportunities that arise where dependency is evident.
We will now return to the average healthy infant in a good holding environment.
III. Seven - 18 months
Mahler defines the overall stage as “Separation Individuation,” which she places from 7 months to about 18 months with several sub phases.
Mahler's sub phase of Seven to ten months is termed the "Differentiation sub phase: Hatching".
Stern’s larger category goes from about 7-9 months until about 18 months, which he calls “The Sense of a Subjective Self.” Both author’s mark the infant’s ability to use language as the end of this category and the beginning of the next.
This section will be divided into Mahler’s categories of Hatching, Early Practicing and Practicing.
Hatching 7-10 months (Stern's 9-12 months)
If this part of the infant's development was a screenplay, it might be titled, "Hello, world!"
The well rested and well fed infant between about seven and ten months is more bright, alert and focused. She notices much more of the outside world. She tries to explore the face, ears and body of the caregiver and the things that are attached to the caregiver. Glasses, watch, earrings and jewelry are not safe from the inquiring little hands. As the infant gains the ability to move by herself, she begins to show interest in and to investigate the world beyond the mother or caregiver. She finds that there are things out there that are interesting and some that are off limits. She is beginning to want to get away from the closeness of the caregiver's embrace. When the infant is held, sometimes she will stiffen up and push away from mother to see others. The baby may initiate the first breaks with mother, by sliding to the floor but remaining close. The infant will scan the outside world of color, sound and movement. Then, as if to evaluate any new information, she will look for any responses with mother or caregiver. The infant seems to be tuned into the responses between the environment, the infant and the caregiver. “Is mother happy, scared, anxious, preoccupied about these outside events?” Although the baby cannot name the emotional responses that occur, the relief or threat is sometimes obvious as a response to the contagious feelings of the mother. The infant is also checking the difference between the strangers and the mother.
In the literature on affect theory and shame, Nathanson writes about the infant's ability to broadcast their feelings. For other people, especially parents, the infant's feelings are contagious. The caregivers become infected with the feelings of the infant and feel compelled to respond. This is a powerful instinctual survival dynamic. Emotionally involved caregivers and parents lack some of the normal empathic wall that exists between adults. The emotionally connected parent feels experiences with the infant in a physically compelling way. So when the infant is happy, the whole room seems to shine. And when the infant is sad, the adult experiences sadness. This response is related to the maternal preoccupation that we discussed in the last section.
How the adult responds to these intense affective experiences will influence the infant’s budding personality. The infant may broadcast feelings that are intolerable for the adult, such as physical pain, dissatisfaction, even anger. The adult may respond to try to shut the infant's feelings down. This response can be quite disruptive for the infant. Recently, I observed people intervene with a small baby who was crying with a severe: "you know better than to cry like that."
There are so many messages being exchanged between the (m)other and the infant during this stage. These subtle exchanges lay down the foundations of faith, personality and worldview. The way the (m)other responds to the initial, tentative self expressions tell the infant what is safe and unsafe, what makes a “good child” and what makes a “bad child”, what scares or delights mother. For example, as the infant makes her first movements towards autonomy, the mother's responses provide a framework for the infant to experience and understand autonomy and independence. If the infant crawls away and the mother is delighted with this new found skill, the child uses that as one memory to build a delight in her skills. The infant is internalizing the complex interaction of the mother's responses. The internal world is being organized into patterns of personality and relationship.
The child is beginning to be more aware of the difference between internal sensations, say a stomach ache, and external stimulations, like being touched. The differentiation between internal and external assists the infant to know the difference between the self and other persons. The beginning lines of the boundaries between the self and others are being laid down during this phase of development. The baby is learning the nuances of boundaries. For example, some caregivers wake a baby up because the caregiver wants some company since she is lonely. This caregiver is not exhibiting respect for the need that the infant has for sleep. Some caregivers do not "read" the infants many messages about boundaries, including being held too closely or too loosely, being overstimulated or being nurtured. The infant is expected to perform for the caregiver, like a toy doll rather than a living human.
At the age of 6-7 months, stranger anxiety marks early evidence of awareness of difference between mother and others. The infant will respond with fear or tears to any new person who approaches. This type of anxiety comes and goes as the infant progresses through the developmental phases. The 8-9 month old may be able to crawl but chooses to stay close to mother since she is beginning to recognize mother is separate and can disappear. There are other times that the stranger anxiety usually occurs. Again the parent's responses to the infant's fear and anxiety contribute to the patterns that the infant is developing. Caregivers may over-respond, validating the infant's fear and sometimes making the fear more intense. Some caregivers may under-respond to this fear, discounting or dismissing the infant's experience as silly or unwarranted. The patterns of over-response or under-response may come in many combinations. When the parent or caregiver can remain calm and responsive to the infant's fear, the infant learns that fear is acceptable and manageable. The fear remains conscious, giving the infant reality based information about the situation.
The mirroring of this early period gives the infant an external emotional representation of her gestures, emotions and experiences. This mirroring allows the infant to confirm her existence and see herself more clearly. At about six months, the quality of the exchange begins to change as the baby become more responsive. Daniel Stern’s book illuminates the understanding of the quality of mirroring that occurs by illustrating the events of “Attunement”. His observational research on early infants documents the importance of the mirroring that occurs between the infant and the caregivers.
Stern describes how the mother matches the emotional expression embedded in the infant’s behavior through her own behavior and vocalizations. Stern found that, often unconsciously, the responsive mother seeks to make a connection with the infant by giving a corresponding, parallel response to the infant’s emotional expression in intensity, timing and/or shape. So, if the infant squeals for 2 seconds, the mother might open her mouth wide, shake her head and raise her eyebrows for that same amount of time, communicating a corresponding affect of excitement. When the mirror is accurate, the infant continues on with the activity as if nothing special occurs. The infant remains in touch with her own experience--unless the response does not connect or correspond to that experience. When there is an intentional event of mis-attunement, the infants as young as 3 months react with mild upset and withdrawal, then attempting to get the partner to reengage. The recreate the experience of mis-attunement, Stern used a “still-faced” experiment where the mother is coached to intentionally "mis-attune" by keeping her face still in response to the infant's lively affect.
The empathic responsiveness and attunement occurred mostly out of the mother’s awareness but it was a frequent part of the interaction for many of the mother-infant pairs in Stern's work. Through this attunement, which is a complex form of interaction, the baby learns that the mother can share the baby’s internal experience. The mother communicates; “I know something about the way you feel.” The infant also comes to see her self more clearly. Her internal world, reflected back in the intensity, timing and shape of the mother’s response, is interpreted back to her. This attunement assists the infant to become aware of and in tune with her self. This type of mirroring and attunement allows for the inborn self to emerge. What a precious and wonderful gift!
Stern’s delightful examples show the complex attunement of the mother to the inner world of the infant and how that attunement is communicated without verbal language.
A nine month old becomes very excited about a toy and reaches for it. As she grabs it, she lets out an exuberant ”aaah!” and looks at her mother. Her mother looks back, scrunches up her shoulders, and performs a terrific shimmy with her upper body, like a go-go dancer. The shimmy lasts only about as long as her daughter’s “aaah!” but is equally excited, joyful and intense.
A nine month old boy bangs his hand on a soft toy, at first in some anger but gradually with pleasure, exuberance, and humor. He sets up a steady rhythm. Mother falls into his rhythm and says, “kaaaaa-bam, kaaaaa-bam,” the “bam” falling on the stroke and the “kaaaaa” riding with the preparatory upswing and the suspenseful holding of his arm aloft before it falls. (Stern, 1985. p.140)
The connection between Attunement, Empathy and Pastoral presence
This attunement is an expression of empathy which is sometimes difficult to capture in a verbatim. I have seen pastoral caregivers communicate this type of empathic attunement in clinical situations. The fleeting expressions and gestures of people in crisis are captured by some pastoral care givers in such a way that the people feel heard, met and known in a powerful way. Can you remember a time when someone listened to you so closely, so accurately that they heard you better than you heard yourself? Perhaps, you can remember an experience where you felt a deep acceptance and understanding. This is may be hard to remember. You may not have had enough of this type of attunement, which means that you deserve to have a lot more in the future! How are you going to position yourself so that you experience this type of attunement?
The concrete descriptions from early childhood give us a new way to see and understand the complexity of empathy. With an understanding of empathic attunement in childhood, I believe that the whole idea of the power of pastoral presence becomes more understandable. Pastoral presence is grounded in attaining access to our own internal responses and using those to mirror the internal world of another person. We become caregivers who suspend our own disbelief, our own needs, our own agenda, for just a while so we can be emotionally present to the other person's perception of reality. Sometimes we try to mimic pastoral care by finding a formula or a set of the "right" words, but this rarely communicates the powerful care that is evident from authentic emotional connection. Pastoral care is not a finely honed performance, but an act of love grounded in the love that we have received. Empathic attunement like this cannot be captured or diagrammed, but it can be learned and honed.
The Infant's Self Image
Every parent and caregiver is continually constructing versions of the baby's inner life, including who they think the baby is and what they think the baby is experiencing. Caregivers read into the baby's expressions, vocalization and behaviors. The baby cries. They say that he's angry or scared or greedy, which shapes how they respond to the cry.
All these interpretations are not lost on the baby. The infant is getting information about he is perceived and understood by the parent. The infant's awareness of the caregiver's interpretations is important as he develops his identity. The infant is tuned into the mother's affect and responses as he develops maps of who he is. The parent's perception of the infant influences the infant's interaction with the world. The image that the infant has of who he is partly created from the parent's perceptions of the infant.
Sometimes the infant's internal experience is not reflected in the parent's response. This can occur for so many reasons. Often, the larger relationships are not "holding" the primary caregiver through physical, emotional and spiritual support. Sometimes the caregiver lacks knowledge or capacity for such intense relationships. When the infant does not get the attunement that he deserves, he misses out on important moments of validation, encouragement and nurture. This is a great loss that will require grieving in later life. Also, the infant may experience shame and rage. Just as stranger anxiety evokes fear in the infant, when the mother responds in an unfamiliar way, the child may feel there is a stranger in his midst. The mother’s lack of attunement intrudes on the infant’s secure attachment in the relationship. The infant can feel violated, abandoned and deeply depressed, even physically threatened with death by the lack of attunement and validation. The baby if forced to learn to modify his self expression in order to get basic validation. This contributes to a false presentation of the self, a false self which we will address more fully in the next section. The abandonment depression or even annihilation terror of the infant is intolerable and leads to defenses that interfere with adult functioning and satisfaction. An important part of the work to become a more fully functioning person is the journey into the deep fear, despair and depression at the core of the false self. This includes an encounter with the deeply painful abandonment depression that often lingers in our preverbal memory.
Stern's book gives many examples of inaccurate mirroring or the effects of mis-matched temperaments between parent and child. One common example of a lack of mirroring would be the child who is just beginning to crawl away from mother and is feeling excited and happy about this marvelous accomplishment. The mother, perhaps because of her own preoccupation or some sense of threat, does not reflect that this is a joyous experience. Perhaps she is afraid that she is beginning to lose the infant who had made her feel so important and beloved. Perhaps she has other losses that the infant temporarily soothed, such as the loss of the idealized marriage partner. The child senses the lack of enthusiasm from the mother which does not match the child's internal response. The child may begin to feel that she is bad or will be abandoned in her natural inclination to separate and may respond in a variety of ways to this bad feeling. The infant begins to mistrust her natural inclinations and begins to forget what her body wants. She does not receive the necessary validation and confirmation of this part of her humanity. The infant loses a felt sense of her own desires and longings, which complicates the evolving awareness of her own identity.
The disapproval and mis-attunement may be very severe, repeated or relatively minor. When the lack of attunement is severe and repeated, the infant fears for his life. Without the caregiver, the infant knows somewhere deep inside that he might die. There are several potential responses to moderate to severe disapproval and mis-attunement. One response to the disapproval may be a sense of shame within the infant, the feeling of being at fault for the loss of the mother's attunement. Another response could be a profound depression, where the infant gives up and becomes listless. The mis-attunement may occur so frequently and with such severity, that the infant experiences hopelessness of ever being what the mother wants, needs, expects. Another response could be anxious and exaggerated efforts to work very hard to avoid the depression, rage or terror. This "manic defense against depression" occurs because the despair may kill you. The infant may inhibit her own inclination towards autonomy in order to be more acceptable to the mother, but she loses an important part of her self.
Let us return to the developing infant. As Winnecott said: "When I look, I am seen, so I exist." Ideally, the infant is allowed to begin 'by existing and not by reacting' The infant is able to move from complete dependence to relative dependence towards interdependence in a way that creates a body self that allows the "individuals live creatively and feel that life is worth living." Inevitably and eventually the infant will face the reality of helplessness. The paradox is that with enough secure attachment, the person will not have to live in denial about the vulnerability, finitude and limits of human existence. The person maintains access to her body, to her emotions, experiences and thoughts in a full way. In secure interdependence, there is an awareness and some degree of acceptance of the total vulnerability which remains an inarticulate mystery at the core of the person. There remains a threat that the true self will be exploited. Yet even in the midst of this threat, the person can attain "relative integrity and spontaneity of the self." I come back to the felt sense of security that is grounded in body, that is influenced but not defined by the community.
When I think of this body felt sense, this awareness of one's emotions and desires, I remember a delightful poem that speaks to this awareness of what the body wants:
You do not have to be good
You do not have to walk on your knees
for a hundred miles through the desert, repenting.
You only have to let the soft animal of your body love what it loves.
Tell me about despair, yours, and I will tell you mine.
Meanwhile the world goes on.
Meanwhile the sun and the clear pebbles of the rain
are moving across the landscapes,
over the prairies and the deep trees,
the mountains and the rivers.
Meanwhile the wild geese, high in the clean blue air,
are heading home again.
Whoever you are, no matter how lonely,
the world offers itself to your imagination,
calls to you like the wild geese, harsh and exciting -----
over and over announcing your place
in the family of things.
Mary Oliver
Alert inactivity
Accurate mirroring includes allowing the infant to be alone, formless and without need. Infant's spend an important part of their day in alert inactivity. Some caregivers or mothers are able to allow the child to be alone and formless. The good enough caregiver can be present to the infant without being intrusive or neglectful out of their own security and comfort with solitude. When the infant experiences the mother as non-demanding and not too anxious, the child has space to discover his own internal life and to come to enjoy solitude. The child can discover that being alone does not mean being abandoned, lonely or rejected by other people. With the ability to enjoy being alone, the child can chose relationships that are fulfilling, rather than anxiously seeking people to fill the emptiness and anxiety.
The mother's own insecurity, neediness or lack of awareness may interfere with her responsiveness to the infant. The mother may overstimulate or over excite the child in order to escape her own loneliness and despair. This over stimulation is overwhelming for the child, who does not have the resources or options to either escape from the impingement of mother or to care for the advanced needs of the mother. The young infant will try to use the power of his gaze to control the impingement; turning away or closing his eyes to avoid over stimulation. The infant may "fall apart" with crying to avoid the mother's intrusion, only to be punished for crying. However some infants are learn to engage the adult in order to get basic needs met. The child who is expected to meet the advanced needs of the parent may alternately feel all-powerful or completely powerless.
Another form of failure in good enough parenting is the mother who denies the child her emotional availability because she does not know or feel comfortable with her own depths. Perhaps she is too eager for the infant to grow up and quickly becomes absorbed in her own pursuits. "She tries to hide her fears and limitations from her child, she is wont to relate to the child by controlling the child's responsiveness to her." This can lead to a feeling of rejection or abandonment for the infant. The infant does not develop a sense of safe solitude.
Winnicott believed that the good enough mother provides ” a perfect environment and it’s gradual withdrawal”. Winnecott admitted that this perfect mothering is required only briefly. The optimal failure is an important part of the development of the personality which we will address later.
Practicing 10 month to about 16-18 months:
The motto for the infant in this part of the screen play might be: "Look out world, Here I come!"
Early practicing:
Beginning when the child starts to crawl, climb and to physically separate from the mother, a whole new and exciting world opens up. The child can physically move across the room and yet remain emotionally connected to the mother. The child may crawl away, then pause and look back at mother for an "emotional refueling". The infant emotionally feeds off the (m)other’s gaze or words that convey safety, security, and energy. “Emotional refueling” is Winnecott’s term for the times when the child visually or physically checks in with the mother to see if she is present and pleased. When this refueling is available, accurate and reliable, the child is free to separate out of a secure bond or attachment with the mother. Out of this secure bonding and attachment, the later separation and individuation can proceed. Although the child now has interest in things outside of the mother, mother is still the primary focus of attention.
This refueling need seems to be present throughout the life span. Families in crisis seem to act on the need when they look for someone to soothe and comfort them. The pastor or the chaplain provides emotional refueling and reassurance that they will be alright by their emotionally stable presence. People can still read emotional tone from across a room...a skill they had at 3 months!
Practicing Proper
During the practicing sub phase proper, the child starts to walk. What a marvelous, exciting achievement! The child is exhilarated by what seems to be limitless possibilities and horizons. Sleeping and eating can't compete with this thrilling activity, so the patterns are often disrupted as the child experiments with new found skills. The child's exhilaration occurs because of the satisfaction of mastering movement. What a feeling of power to be able to get around on your own legs, when you are used to being carried or crawling. The child gets great pleasure out of this new found autonomy with her body. The child looks drunk with self satisfaction. During this period of exhilaration, the infant is not as easily upset by the mother's brief absence. The emotional attachment and engagement with other people is growing.
The naturally grandiose child of this age seems impervious to failure and sometimes to minor injury and pain. She can fall down without noticing the sting because the exhilaration of movement and autonomy is like an magic elixir. She becomes an emotional and physical exhibitionist, showing off and seeking attention. The acceptance, admiration and attunement of the parents allows the child’s self to solidify with healthy initiative and self assertion. Out of self awareness and self acceptance, the child begins to develop motivation and purpose, to feel good about taking her own initiative and direction in life. A more mature form of narcissism can develop from this archaic, primary narcissism. The hunger for affirmation, for attention and for responsive mirroring is healthy here and, if it is adequately met, will allow for less dramatic neediness in later life.
This happy time can sometimes fool the parents into thinking they can handle another child. The child appears so secure and happy that the parents may miss the dependency of the infant. Sometimes a second child is conceived at about this time. However, there are big time switchbacks in this road to development that will inevitably come at about the time that other child would arrive!
The need for acceptance and validation from adults other than the primary (m)other is at it's height. The other caregivers responsiveness creates an oasis from the mother. The child is in a "love affair with the world" where the world seems to be at her disposal. The child has the perception of being all powerful, of omnipotence, where her desires are instantly brought into being. The responsive parents allow this to occur by protecting the child from danger, reading the needs of the child and setting kind limits. The giddy excitement can be contagious and the caregivers enjoy the child's excitement. The energy is not just because of newly found abilities but also because of the escape from the intense dependency with mother.
When the child sustains an injury or a threat that is enough to break through the shell of omnipotence, the child will react with shock and disorientation. The child's exhilaration deflates, the mood will be lowered and the child will maintain a watchful attitude, often with a flat affect. This reaction seems to conserve energy which is turned inward to sustain balance and cohesion. When the balance cannot be sustained the child will fall apart emotionally into sobs and physical responses of withdrawal.
Separation is gradually occurring, yet the child still sees the (m)other as an extension or appendage of the child. The child looks for emotional refueling and other sustaining responses from the (m)other. The brief look or the slight touch of the mother's hem is often used for reassurance and a renewed energy for exploration. The secure (m)other provides a gentle push, not a shove, for the growing child. This gentle push occurs as the (m)other not only allows but expresses enjoyment and encouragement of the child's growing ability to function at a distance from her. She enjoys the child's entrance into the world of autonomy and risk. Instead of responding to what she thinks the child should need or to her own projected fears, she responds to the actual nonverbal and physical requests of the child. There is usually some grief and loss over the separation with the child, which was both physically and emotionally gratifying. However the grief is managed by the mother and balanced by the rewards of returning to other pursuits.
During this time, the child needs to have her inflated view of herself, her "infantile grandiosity," mirrored and validated. The child is full of herself, delighted with her new ability to get around and get away from the mother. This exhibitionistic, showy, pretentious child exhibits a grandiosity that may challenge the mother's own particular emotional issues. The mother who responds well to this stage is delighted with the child's capacity without exaggerating the child's ability to function as an adult.
This occurs with the mother who:
is aware of her own inflated view of herself,
is reconciled with her own grandiosity,
is aware of and reconciled with her partner's grandiosity,
is in relationships and activities that give her attention and validation is not threatened or injured by the separation.
When the mother does not need the child to take care of her or to need her, the child is freed to develop as the marvelous unique human person he is created to be.
The mother encourages and enjoys the relationship that the child has with the father or others. She can use the time as a break and an opportunity to re-invest in the relationship with the father or in other life pursuits. This is a much needed break before the incredible challenges of the next phase; the terrific two's. Yet the mother who is comfortable with the dependency of the child will continue to provide mirroring from a distance.
The “average devoted mother” or “good enough mother” assists the child to feel good about both autonomy and dependency. By responding with quiet availability, the mother matches the developmental pace of the child without interfering or becoming either anxious or withholding. With this mirroring, the child begins to solidify a healthy self esteem. The experience of safe omnipotence provides the foundation of healthy trust in self and others, of confidence, of self soothing and of self regulation.
However, there are many ways that the caregivers can respond in ways that are less than ideal. The mother may be threatened by the grandiosity of the "love affair" for a variety of reasons. Her own self esteem may be shaky, her support systems or “contextual holding” may be minimal or her own grandiosity may be unacceptable to her. She may have had some severe disappointments of her own goals and dreams, which created a need to protect the child from such disappointments. She may feel that she needs to keep the child from feeling “too good” in a world that will eventually present disappointment and pain. She wants her child to be better defended, to experience less pain than she had. She wants to teach the child a variation of the expression of “I don’t need you so you can’t hurt me.”
She may be afraid that other people will think she is a bad mother if the child is too “cocky” or has too much “pride”. She may look outside of herself for affirmation that she is doing a "good job" and may hear messages that tell her to be more strict or more lenient. Even with good intentions, the mother may attempt to “protect” the child from some imagined later disappointment. This anxiety forces the mother to confront the child prematurely with either the limitations of the child or the mother, or both. Such confrontation may decrease the mother's anxiety about having a "cocky" child who is “too big for her britches”, The prohibitions may be about having "selfish", "passive" or "sissy" child. However, such confrontation creates premature, sometimes overwhelming insecurity for the child. The premature confrontations with unnecessary limits can create a hole in the self esteem the is difficult to refill. The child does not learn the basic trust that provides the foundation of hope, even in the midst of the inevitable limitations of being human.
On the other hand, the mother may fail by “believing” in the child's infantile grandiosity. The mother may be overly invested in the child's new found power. She may idealize the child and want the sometimes contagious emotions of exhilaration to continue. She may need for the child to be "special" in order to take care of her or her image of herself. Also the mother may begin to abandon the still very needy infant, seeing this confidence as an indication that the child is ready to be autonomous. The parent may begin to treat the child as if he is developmentally further along than the child could possibly be. An example would be expecting the one year old to drink milk without spilling it or to remember what is breakable. Another unrealistic expectation is that the child will take care of the mother’s feelings, be empathic and accepting. The unrealistic myth that this baby is more mature than his age does a disservice to the development of realistic self evaluation and positive self esteem. With such pressure, the child cannot accept the normal limitations that are a part of being human. The child's neediness and dependency, which is still pronounced threatens the caregiver. From such pressure to perform, the child may develop a mixed experience of her own power, sometimes feeling omnipotent, sometimes impotent. The response of the other caregiver’s influences how the dynamics are internalized. One theory for the narcissistic personality disorder is that one parent idealizes the child while the other one humiliates even the healthy parts of the child's exhibitionism.
Self development and self awareness are created by both involvement with and separation from other people. During practicing, the child is beginning the life-long negotiation of this paradox. A core dilemma is that in order to be in fulfilling relationship, one must separate. In other words, you find yourself in the context of community which encourages you to be separate. "Good enough" development includes access to others without the loss of the self.
Transitional object/transitional space
Many children have a favorite teddy bear, a blanket or other article that they love during this developmental period. D.W. Winnicott noticed the relationship between children and their beloved objects. He called the object the "transitional object" and he thought it was very important in the psychological development of the child.
This article or object serves in the transition between the total dependency on the very powerful (m)other towards the growing autonomy of the developing child. The child begins to realize that she cannot control the presence or actions of the comforting (m)other. Another comforting object is given special power to substitute for mother. When the parent is not available or not enough, the child can remain separate and safe without being overwhelmed as long as the object is supplied. The object is not quite the mother, but is invested with some of the qualities of the mother for soothing and comfort. Yet the object is more controllable than the mother. The child uses the article to bridge the distance between the uncontrollable, sometimes unavailable, mother and the self.
The parents or caregivers cooperate with the creation of the comforting transitional object by not questioning/challenging the total control of the child over the transitional object or challenging the importance of the transitional object. The parents acknowledge the power of transitional object by working hard to find it and make it available to the child under stress. The transitional object is somewhere between the world of parent and the world of child, allowing the child to test the movement towards being separate and not embedded in the relationship with the parents.
The concept of the transitional space that was provided by the transitional object, such as the teddy bear or blanket, was very important to Winnecott. He emphasized the increasing freedom of the child to create illusion, fantasy, and to play in that transitional space just outside of facts and objective reality. Whereas Freud emphasized health as freedom from illusion or other transcendent experiences, Winnecott valued the nebulous, mystical aspects of human experience. Winnicott acknowledged and explored the importance of illusion, playfulness and mystery in the development of the human person. The importance of mystery and playfulness points towards seeing religion and art in the important transitional space between inner and outer reality, between fantasy and fact, between the proven and the unproven. He proposed that the “third, intermediary and transitional relationship between hallucinatory omnipotence and the recognition of the objective reality” was important in development. When this space is acknowledged and recognized, the growing child's imagination can be valued and nurtured towards creative expression. The child can learn to enjoy the mystical aspects of human experience; those aspects of human endeavor that are not completely rational or within our control. Also, imagination is an important part of empathy, as we discussed in earlier presentations.
The transitional space occurs "in between" poles of experience; somewhere between fantasy and reality, between subjective and objective, between our inner and outer reality. Both children and adults continually vacillate between the poles of total control over ‘subjective objects’ of illusion and less control over people and events that are separate . Without using the term, the complex understanding of this inner space is referenced in the literature about art and creativity where the person must wrestle with the transitional space between the artist's or creator's vision of what can be and what is already in existence.
The transitional experience is important as an invisible, sometimes created or discovered, sometimes mysteriously present, numinous plane of reality. In this space, the person can play with ideas and possibilities in a way that allows for creative, original thoughts. Perhaps artists and poets can best describe this place. “In transitional experience, we maintain access to the most private well spring of our thoughts and imagery, without being held accountable for them in the clear and harsh light of objective reality. “ We are allowed to fantasize about anything without fear that our thinking will bring about disaster. The transitional experience is that important yet illusive area between inner and outer reality, between fact and fantasy, between subjective experience and objective reality. The transitional area is where we work out our interdependency, our identity and our soul. Spiritual and religious awareness are part of this invisible, real space. Some people write about how our image of God serves as a transitional object to give people comfort and structure in their interior world.
In pastoral care, we hold visions of what the persons can be and what they are, with what life has been and what life will be, with the intersection between the facts of an event and the meaning which we make out of those facts. For example, a pastor goes in the room of someone who is accused of physically abusing a child. She works to let her mind vacillate between an awareness of the person's pain and the natural identification with the child who was abused. She uses her imagination to see him as both victim and perpetrator, eliciting both compassion and clear limits in terms of his accountability for his actions. She remembers his stories of his father's abuse of him, and hears how helpless and fearful he is. This example shows some of the relationship between imagination, empathy and self definition.
The ability to understand, value and use transitional experience can assist us as pastoral care givers to tap into our creative, healing potential. The transitional space offers the arena where we can understand and use how healing occurs through prayer, meditation, art, writing and other acts of creation.
Some people do not validate this growing aspect of the child's awareness. They may squelch or even discount the child's need for a blanket or teddy bear, the transitional object. They shame the child for "being a baby" or speaking about how disgusting the article has become from being dragged everywhere the child goes. In these and other ways, the caregivers do not acknowledge, and may actively denigrate the child's growing subjective experience. This subjective experience includes the child's interior, unprovable world of ideas, beliefs, and feelings. An example of a child's subjective experience is that she desires, loves and needs the power of the wonderful yellow bear, but the caregiver sees the dirty, smelly piece of cloth. The discounting of the subjective experience occurs for many reasons, including the caregivers own lack of support and nurture. The caregiver may be so removed from their own internal subjective world that they cannot stay tuned to or empathize with the child's self expression.
Another article will address the important terrible or terrific two's. Cathy