Power and Authority in early childhood development


January 2020

 

What we learn about power and authority affects us deeply.   Power, safety and trust are intricately connected as the pursuit of safety is a core driver of behavior.  These dynamics are everywhere.

  

Power is the ability to act, to influence, to direct or to control.  

 

Sources of power include social group, knowledge, affiliation or affection, role or position, and the possession of tools of enforcement. Authority, when used as a separate word from power, is the ability or authorization to exercise power.  Gender, class and race have important implications for our understanding and use of power, but they do not define the issues.  The driving forces are often found in the early years, and the intersection of gender, race and class affect early childhood development.   

 

Also there is the power to refuse to act, which may be the only power some people possess, so they call upon this skill more frequently.   

 

Often we are unconscious of our ways of assuming or undermining power.  We have subtle ways of assuring our safety and delegating authority that are out of our awareness.  We make assumptions about who can act, who should be in charge and who has the right to make certain decisions.  We communicate our power status in multiple ways; body posture, vocal tone, word choice, volume, gesture and many more. 

 

Questioning or interrogating authority can be seen as a good, bad or neutral - though most often those in power do not way to surrender power.    We may submerge our need for safety under a veneer of power, always trying to achieve the safety of not needing anyone or anything.   

  

In childhood we develop our assumptions and responses to our power and the power of others.  After childhood, we apply the lessons we learned about our power and the power of others, often without reviewing their continued truth or relevance.  

 

If a child is consistently over powered by an aggressive caregiver or given too much power over the caregiver, there will be difficulties with power in later life. 

 

We learn a great deal about power from the first two to three years of life.  For most people there is an important  “power pivot” that occurs about 15-36 months.   

 

This age and stage is sometimes called the "Terrible Two’s.”  Through changes in cognitive and motor development, the child has more ability to know their own mind and to imagine possibilities.  The child usually  and hopefully gets into various “battles of the will” with caregivers as they explore the boundaries of their own power and the power of others.   

 

In general, this time is marked by the child exploring the world through the numerous physical and emotional abilities she is gaining quickly.  This exploration will occur with the level of vigor and energy that characterizes the child's temperament.  During this transition, there is a leap forward in terms of speech and movement.  The child may be in constant motion; running, climbing, pulling, and jumping.  At other times, she is engaged in activities that stretch her concentration and imagination.  She may become absorbed in the outline of sunshine on the floor or the texture of leaves, or in the mechanics of wheels.  Alongside the physical and cognitive changes,  the child is developing and expressing a will and mind of her own. 

 

Language is evolving, developing and changing the brain.   The words "NO" and "mine" become popular.     

 

Gaining language can be a mixed blessing. On one hand, to name something gives the child the ability to share an internal experience or external reality with another person, as well as the ability to more clearly communicate needs and desires.  The child learns that she can communicate what she wants in ways besides crying or gesturing.  However, just because she expresses something, even very strongly, does not make her wishes, wants, desires happen.  The contrast between sharing a demand and the outcome of that sharing is an education in the use of POWER.   When she gets what she wants, there is a feeling of power, control and delight.  When she does not find satisfaction from the caregiver, or when her strategies are thwarted, the child may try several different approaches and with each attempt, learn different lessons.  Sometimes she will attempt to woo the caregiver to cooperate, only to find that the caregiver does not provide perfect responses.  Sometimes she will try "force" and find out the response of the adult to such pressure.  Nothing may work, which is frustrating, confusing and sometimes overwhelming for the child.  The child has no skills to absorb the messages about power, control and authority and few methods to modify, delay, understand or decrease her frustration.    

 

No matter who well she learns to communicate, her experience can never be totally communicated through words.  Words are only an approximation of reality.  Also, as part of gaining language, other people begin to define what is reality for the child.  They use their words to tell her what she is experiencing.  THIS IS HUGE in terms of development.  Parents and caregivers begin to name internal experience, such as "you shouldn't be angry" and "stop crying; you are being selfish".  One parent may report to the other how the child has been;  "we've had a bad day today, he was fussy all morning and now nothing satisfies him."  Compare that to a report that says; "we've had a hard day today, he was tired and did not feel good all morning and nothing seems to make him feel any better."  These small stories that define reality are constantly swirling around; the tone, tenor and words of these stories that are told to others and to the child are important in the developing identity and in how the child frames reality.  

 

The physical and cognitive gains highlight and influence the psychological development.  With these growing skills in language and mobility, the child experiences both the excitement of autonomy and the loneliness of isolation.  When she says that she wants milk and she gets the milk; the response to the power to act, the experience of controlling her environment,  is exhilaration.  When she says she wants to play in the toilet, her clearly stated desires are not warmly acknowledged.  The limitations of language and the isolation from the caregiver confront the child, deflating the thrills of the feeling all powerful.  

 

The awe-full reality of powerlessness intrudes on the vulnerable child.  Gradually or suddenly the child is learning about mortality and limitations.  The awareness of separation from the security, protection and bond with the caregiver increases as the child develops.  In so many ways, the child is entering the broad horizon of the world beyond the crib and the arms of caregivers. Threat and danger intrude on the child’s awareness.  She comes to realize her feelings of power are transient, sometimes confusing and overwhelming.   it is a big world out there and she is a small person who is vulnerable to pain and abandonment.  In many separate ways, events and experiences, the child is becoming aware that this separate caregiver does not always protect the child from danger and pain.  

 

Disagreements and refusals can be personal affronts to the little person.  The dawning awareness of the caregiver as a separate person can be startling and there are no words to capture this threat.  This massively powerful being who controls her destiny and very life is not always in agreement nor available to the whims and needs of the child.   Eventually the child becomes aware that there are threats that this big person cannot or will not dissolve.  The caregiver cannot protect the child from all harm. 

 

During this time, numerous limitations and frustrations confront the child.  There may be a dawning awareness of vulnerability,  which may mean repeating earlier stranger or separation anxiety.  Even in an ideal world, the child has high needs for support, reassurance and help, yet she is intermittently unable to accept them. She may deny and avoid the need for help because she wants the heady feeling of being separate and autonomous.   She may feel angry at the person who can supply help, resenting the reality that she cannot "do it myself."  She may be angry at those who would help simply because they are not as upset or needy as she is.  

 

How does the parent or caregiver respond when this child becomes disappointed, confused, scared and angry by the caregiver's inevitable failures?    No parent or caregiver can provide perfect protection or immediate gratification.  Crisis occurs when the child is confronted by inevitable limits without adequate tools for ignoring or dealing with the limits. The crisis may be within the child in the form of intensely painful and conflicting emotions.  These may become "tantrums" and inconsolable crying of the child.   The child of this age will alternate between angry battling for autonomy and clinging, helpless dependency.  There can be intense negativity, as the child uses the new found ability to use language to thwart adults with the use of "NO!"  The child may become demanding and tenacious at the most inopportune times.  He will defiantly announce "No" to each and every request, including such cruel and unusual "requests" as to eat the food on the tray without throwing it on the wall.  

 

The strong willed child will dissolve into utter misery, with screaming, tears and physical collapse at the limits set by the caregivers. Also he becomes overwhelmed with many emotions as he alternates between the need for closeness and the growing need for distance.  Anger, sadness, longing, helplessness, and vulnerability all mix together to create periods of internal chaos.  

 

An early form of ambivalence occurs as the child seeks separation but fears abandonment; wants closeness but fears being engulfed or intruded upon.  A different child may present a compliant and calm exterior that belies the anxieties and fears simmering below the surface.  The anxiety or anger may bubble up in their body through illness.    

 

Some reconciliation and resolution of this crisis is necessary for psychological health.  Many caregivers are so burdened by other demands of modern life that this important crucible of growth is not handled well.  Instead of holding the polarities many caregivers overbalance on one side or the other.  

 

The struggles of this age are the training ground where the child learns to deal with relative power in the midst of relative powerlessness.  The caregiver may experience the struggle as regression for the child who seemed so secure after their first birthday.   The caregiver’s responses to the child's differentiation and intense periods of disintegration will shape and hopefully assist in the formation of the child's psychological understanding of key issues such as individuation, authority, power and attachment.

 

The response of the caregiver to the child's anger, separation, terror and sadness affects the child's developing personality.  

 

For healthy personality development, the imperfection of the environment should become evident in small manageable doses so that the child is not overwhelmed with fear, powerlessness, or rage.  There are many biological influences that can affect this stage of development.  These are beyond this article and require deeper conversation.  

 

For most children, ”The mother's  ‘graduated failure of adaptation' is essential to the development of separation, differentiation and realization."   This means that the caregiver will fail and that the work is to fail with grace and with the support of a community.    The caregiver's responses to the self expression of the child will come out of the blend of the child's temperament and the caregiver's personality and experience. 

 

Some folks encourage the clinging dependency of the child at this stage in the service of their own needs.   Other caregivers encourage a radical separation that does not adequately acknowledge the dependency needs of the small child.  Some folks stifle the expression of conflict or intense emotions.  “My way or the highway” is one way caregivers stifle conflict; another way would be for the caregiver to to be hurt and sad at the conflict.  

 

Both responses do not contribute to developing good patterns of power and conflict management or emotional awareness.  When conflict and intense emotions are denied, shamed or suppressed, avoidance, hiddenness or denial  are encouraged.  Sometimes this suppression of conflict can cause the child’s anxiety to turn inward towards the self, creating depression, a loss of a sense of self, or a sense of a bad self.  

 

The trick is that the child needs to have both sides of his dilemma reflected back to him.  

 

He needs to be nurtured in his dependency, encouraged in his separation and emotionally held together in the midst of rage, sadness and anxiety.  

 

Self STORIES:  In the stories that the child overhears about himself in these experiences, he needs to have a wide variety of his needs, feelings and experiences framed as "good".  The struggle against either enmeshment or isolation and distance is waged in these stores.   Personality traits and dynamics are being forged in the space between what the child presents in terms of needs and wants and what the caregiver can tolerate or bless.  

 

No parent or caregiver is perfect, nor needs to be.  Failure is inevitable as the caregiver allows the child to learn about relative power and relative powerlessness; neither pole is the whole story.   

 

What is most helpful to the child is a reflective caregiver who can have firm and flexible responses that are created in community with other reasonable people without retaliation for the inevitable injuries of the parent or caregiver -child relationship.   

 

MODELS:  The child learns a great deal about how to deal with the emotions and experiences through the models of the caregivers.  The child  may imitates or reacts against the caregiver's responses, attitudes and patterns.  Children may be like video cameras that tape you and play back a version of you at inopportune times!   The child will "play back" many of the your responses, which may seem endearing and/or maddening.  For example a child may play back to a hated pattern, for example the dreamy preoccupation with her own thoughts, like her father, but receive the unconscious anger from the mother at the father for that pattern.  

 

EMOTIONS OF ONES OWN

This is the time when the child is first aware of experiencing a complex mix of emotions as the child's own.  Before now the experience of the self and other is more mixed up.  The child is becoming aware that they have emotions that others do not share.  They have emotional boundaries.  

 

The response of the caregiver to the feelings of the child will influence the child's awareness of the child's own emotions, the child's response to his emotions  and the way the child deals with the emotions of others.   The child learns good emotional boundaries from caregivers who have them.   

 

The role of the caregivers varies as they attempt to allow the child's emotions to affect them without overwhelming or defining them.  

 

When the child expresses anger that he cannot go outside on a brutally cold day, the caregiver acknowledges the anger, without apology, retribution or regret about the need to remain indoors.  The emotion of anger is accepted and acknowledge, even the pain of the anger is recognized.  “When you yell, I can tell you are obviously upset; I get upset too when I cannot do what I want to do.”  The yelling is addressed without punishment, withdrawal and without caving in. 

The caregiver is  able to make the majority of decisions about the child's welfare without becoming too defined by their own inadequacy and helplessness.  Yet the caregiver is able to respond and express concern about the child's emotional responses.   Such a balance is impossible to maintain all the time and difficult to maintain consistently, especially without adequate personal support for the caregiver or parent.  

 

The negotiation of power and control issues at this young age is the precursor for the time when the child is learning to control more of her impulses, to create her self-control and to participate in community.  Robert Kegan, (1994,p. 79) in his writing about moral development, recognizes "...the child's need for parents to exercise power on behalf of convictions, exert control, be righteously indignant and even express moral outrage….”   

… (The child needs) a sure sense that someone is in charge who believes in something and will stand for those beliefs.” 

 

Opportunities to exercise effective parenting around issues of power and control begin long before the child reaches 10 years of age!   The child at two is laying down the important emotional foundations around the negotiation of power, authority and control.

 

The needs for support, encouragement, blessing and connection are in lifelong tension with the needs for separation, autonomy, challenge, and control.  Several authors acknowledge this tension in various ways.  

 

Mahler saw the theme of attachment and separation as a primary dilemma for development.  Garanzini says in his attachment cycle that we are on a never ending process of attachment, loss and reattachment.  Harriet Learner states this truth in this way:  Dependency needs are a universal aspect of human experience.  The struggle to achieve a healthy integration of passive - dependent longings and active autonomous strivings constitutes a life-long developmental task for both men and women."   She goes on to acknowledge that women have been disproportionately stereotyped as dependent, passive and in need of stronger attachments than men.   We begin to see dependency/autonomy and passivity/activity as human characteristics that are part of the dynamic integration of both connection and separation.  

 

D.W.  Winnecott's "good enough mother” discusses how the caregiver inevitably fails to meet all the child's needs yet continues to provide a “holding environment.”   The holding environment is a context which contains the child's aggressions without retaliation or abandonment.   (Winnecott often refers to the individual mother but the reality is that caregiving requires a village.)  I do not see how one person could ever adequately hold or address the complex needs of even one infant.   

 

The caregiver relationship  to the child allows for a wide variability of responses from anger to joy to caring to excitement.  The adequate caregiver at this stage is neither consistently distant nor impinging, but is usually available without a great deal of anxiety.  Without excessive anxiety and with a certain amount of security, the caregiver can first, notice and then, mirror a wide range of emotional responses from the child.  The child learns to be aware of the exciting complexity of what it means to be human without a sense of fear or shame.   The caregiver is able to allow the gradual process of separation to occur, to allow the child to learn to like being alone and how to be with other people.  The child can find the life that is within her and create a unique way of negotiating the world.  With accurate caring reflection, the child sees that hatred does not destroy  the caregiver.  The child begins to trust that, even when there is anger or hatred or misunderstanding, acceptance is possible.  This foundational sense of trust and hopefulness would occur when the caregiver remains emotionally present when the child was angry, sad or misbehaving.  When the caregiver allows the child to impact her without completely overwhelming her,  the child begins to experience reasonable, relative power.  This relative power in the midst of relative powerlessness is essential to healthy intimacy and personal authority.

 

The relationship that the child has with the other parent or other caregivers is very important as a safe haven for the child, as a release valve for the intensity of the primary relationship and as a primary supporter and encourager of the primary parent.  The relationship between the caregivers is foundational in the psychological health of the child.  When the relationship is conflicted, often one caregiver will become over invested in the child and under-invested in the other caregiver

 

To the extent that one parent or caregiver uses the child to replace the emotional relationship with the other parent,  the child's psychological health may be damaged.  The burden of being the primary love object of either parent is often too demanding for a child.  If the caregivers collude with the emotional  “marriage” between one parent and the opposite sex child for their own reasons, the child loses.  The child bears the guilt and lives with a dread of retaliation inherent in the secret knowledge of being responsible for the demise of the relationship.  At some point, the child is old enough to intentionally attempt to divide the parents from one another.  "If the parents resist being broken apart, the child feels confronted, and though perhaps angry or frustrated, less guilty and anxious."

 

Some of the important dilemmas for this phase are:

how well does the caregiver accept the indecisiveness and contradictory demands of the child?  Can the parents be playful and relaxed in the face of defiance without shaming or discounting the child?

 

At about this time, 15 - 36 months,  the child is developing a stable  concept of the self and stable concepts of others.  

  

Through periods of regression and progress, the child is developing a stable inner representation of the caregiver that is available for comforting, confronting or dialogue.  The child is developing more complex images of other people and of God and the larger universe, whether the transcendent aspects is named or not.  These internal images of faith and power become important to the child.  If the child has some formal religious education or experience, this is supplemented by her experience with the intermediate space where God and imagination appear.  

 

In this experience the child can develop and tap internal sources of positive soothing and comfort.  Then the child is more able to experience joy, satisfaction and security for the self and from others.  

 

The child is beginning to develop a sense of separate identity.  Many places and people have been giving clues and telling stories about who they think this child is.  The child is beginning to synthesize this information into some patterns which will become his identity, his core sense of self.  

 

He may comply or defy some of the identifications that are given to him in an effort to forge his own unique identity.  In group experiences , the child may learn to recite; “I am lovable and capable”.  At home, he hears; “Bad boy!  Shame on you for hitting your sister.”   At play school, he hears;  “good boys pick up after themselves.”  Who is he?  What does he want?   

 

The formation of identity continues throughout the life span as new changes and challenges occur.   Maturity cannot be seen as independence but as age appropriate dependency.  

 

At each phase, as new capabilities and skill emerge,  the caregiver and the child lose the particular balance of autonomy and dependency and forge a new one.  The bonds of one age are lost and the bonds of another age are born.  Different patterns can occur, such as an increasing ability to separate, to depend, to tolerate ambivalence - mixed feelings - about the self and others.  The maturing child who received adequate support and reasonable challenges comes  to see and accept the complexity of other people's interior worlds.  Even with good support and challenge, the process of "holding the object together" in all the goodness and badness is painful.  Depression, anxiety and guilt occur and must be faced as the child begins the long process of acknowledging the limits of one's love, the uncertainty of the future and the reality of ambivalence.  

 

Regression back to a previous level of maturity occurs with new challenges and crisis. Meeting the child in the regression is part of the bonding that occurs.  When a child is sick and needy and dependent, the bond is strengthened and the bond is tested when the child feels most strong and independent.   

 

Some people are unable or do not learn to tolerate the pain of these realities.  Therefore, they retain maps of reality where many defenses are active.  Defenses are patterns of habit that seek to stabilize the self against pain.  Often the defense solution becomes more problematic than the initial threat.  The use of many defenses distorts relationships.    

 

The person become more or less dissatisfied with the self and other.  Two common defenses, which are addressed more extensively in separate chapters are splitting and projective identification.  Splitting is part of "all or nothing" thinking which is a common way to avoid facing the complexity of reality.  To the extent that the poles of good and bad are not integrated, the person sees other people as either punishing, withholding,  rejecting or gratifying.  We will address this further under the entire presentation on "splitting."

 

 

As we seek to create healing for others, we see people who either have not gained this level or maturity or who are regressed back to a previous stage of their development.  

 

For example in crisis, how we set boundaries if affected.  We may set our boundaries too rigidly or too loosely.   We give all the indicators of exhaustion but cannot say we need rest or solitude.  We cannot deal with the inevitable ambiguity of the crisis situation.  Simply to keep on functioning, we deny  or amplify parts of ourselves or others.  Our emotions may be over determined, so when there may be cause for some irritation, we feel rage.   We easily feel insulted or injured.  We lack any ability to access our own soothing, so we may be excessively dependent on others or defensively detached.  

 

What is your way of regressing?   Can you think of other ways that you have been yourself or seen people in crisis that might relate to these developmental tasks?

 

Daniel Stern articulates a developmental stage for the child who is around three years of age.  At this stage the child begins to tell her own story, “to weave together an autobiographical narrative”.  I have addressed the importance of the story that the parents create about and for the child.  Now the child will use the building blocks of her own experience and the stories she has absorbed to create her own narratives.  This is a complex process that continues throughout life for each of us.  The story that a person has developed about himself will be important at times of crisis.  

 

Does the person see himself as strong, as weak, as capable, as tolerant, as innately safe?  How is this related to how he sees God?  

 

Fill a page with ways you complete the sentence:  “I am a person who….” and for each one write down the opposite.  “I am a person who never…”

 

 

A woman whose mother had died said that she thought of herself as someone who believed in miracles and the power of prayer.  During her mother's illness, she had "pulled out all the stops", getting every church and individual she knew to pray for her mother's healing.  But her mother died.  As she spoke about the loss, she said she did not know who she was or who God was.  She felt abandoned by God, but also by many significant people who could not handle the expressions of grief, anger and the questions that she had about her faith.  Her identity was changing, although she was in her 60's, because the old resolutions are not working in light of the new information that she was allowing herself to acknowledge.   

 

True Self or Real Self

 

Even the most devoted caregiver inevitably fails to meet all the needs of the child.   Winnecott’s “good enough mother” and Mahler's "average devoted mother" are not perfect and will not satisfy the child.   (As I have said before, these authors stress one significant person, almost always the mother.  However the reality is that other people serve this function for the child.)  The adequate caregiver provides an adequate but not perfect holding environment which contains the child’s aggression and rage without retaliation or abandonment.  This caregiver models a durable commitment  that is reliable  and consistent, which permits a wide variation of emotional responses within the child and in the relationship.  From anger to joy, from caring to distance, from excitement to despair; the child is able to experiment with different attitudes, values and assumptions without undue confrontation.  The caregiver also models and expresses a wide range of congruent emotional responses.  The caregiver is neither consistently distant nor impinging, but usually available without a great deal of anxiety.  The caregiver is able to allow the gradual process of separation to occur, to allow the child to learn to like being alone and how to be with other people.  The child can find a life of her own.  This person is usually not anxious over his or her own performance as a parent or caregiver, instead feeling reasonably secure in the contextual holding environment and in the day to day  outcome of this child's development.

 

With accurate mirroring and optimal frustration, the child experiences the reality that hatred or anger do not destroy or fatally wound the caregiver.  Acceptance is possible.  This would occur when the caregiver remains emotionally present even when the child is angry, withholding or “misbehaving”.  This will depend upon the story that the caregiver or parent has created to understand who the child is and what the child is experiencing.  When the caregiver interprets the child’s behavior in an empathic way, such as “she must be tired and hungry”, the caregiver responds with a different reaction than the caregiver who interprets the same behavior as an intentional power struggle or insult.   As I have said before: when the caregiver allows the child to impact her without completely overwhelming her, the child learns reasonable, relative power.

 

When the child is adequately and consistently mirrored, the child can see the self as separate and constant while seeing the other as separate and not completely controllable.  The child begins to realize that she does have an impact on the environment but that the impact is not ultimate, dangerous or annihilating.  

 

What consequences do you think such a belief has on adult functioning?  

 

I believe that this consistent, reliable presence that is durable even in the midst of some conflict can serve a helper, healer, chaplain and counselor.  The helper will sometimes serve as the target to over determined anger or intense emotions of other kinds.  Can the helper remain present, be impacted without being overwhelmed?  Can the helper set compassionate limits, make some mistakes and keep on coming back to the underlying concerns of the patient, family or staff?   The helper who is able to rely on her or his own contextual holding environment will have a far greater chance of remaining consistent and reliable!

 

 

With this type of responsive parenting, the child’s True self emerges.  The true self is an important concept that emerges out of the belief that the personality is already seeded in the infant, awaiting the soil that will allow it to grow and thrive.   The true self might be correlated with the authentic, core self, the spirit of God, the soul, the core or the image of God within the person.  

 

The characteristics of the true self include the capacity to be spontaneous, creative, free and loving.   If enough of the true self is developed, the person’s creative potential can be reached.  I would correlate the access to the true creative, spontaneous self to an experience of abundant life.    As part of that type of abundant living,  the person can tolerate and use the creative tension between inner and outer reality, between subjective reality and objective reality to live fully in community.  Some of the literature on creativity and the “artist within” speaks to and deepens the awareness of this creative tension.  The true self can use the space necessary for self expression yet remain in dialogue with a responsive community.  The true self has access to power within relationship, without the need to use power over or to be powerless against others  

 

A balanced awareness of the emotional part of the person is a very important road to finding the true self.    Sometimes the emotions have been seen as threatening and as inferior to the intellectual, cognitive structures of thought and reasoning.  Sometimes they have been seen as the only truth, as the only source of wisdom.   For this and other reasons, emotional expression was associated with women and oppressed.  Also in our culture, emotions may not be developed because they do not contribute to the conceptions of success or winning.   For a fascinating reflection and understanding concerning  the role of emotions, please read Donald Nathanson’s Shame and Pride; Affect, Sex, and the Birth of the Self.  

 

 In many families, only a narrow range of emotions and behaviors are acceptable.   Shame becomes a primary part of the self when so much of what is human is censored.  The energy that could be used by the true self for abundant living or for relationship building instead is spent in suppression  or self defense.  Another chapter will focus on shame in personality development and in our culture.   Perhaps for some other cultures, the cognitive function might be submerged and not used as a pathway towards self awareness and relationship. 

 

FALSE SELF

 

The false self is developed out of compromise to the demands of the external world.  Everyone develops some false self through the necessity of living in community.  However, when the demands for compliance from the caregivers and the environment are extreme, the person loses access to the true self.  Instead of developing and accessing the interior  world,  the child becomes anxiously attuned to the claims and requests of other people.  He fails to develop his awareness of his own needs, wishes, desires and true core responses.  The child is not given the space to be formless long enough for a real/true self to become firm and emerge.  This is often because the primary parent lacks a sufficient “contextual holding environment” for her own interior world  where  needs are sufficiently met.  When the parent is overburdened, unsupported and without resources, the child absorbs the tension and responds to the external demands.  At some core level, the child may sense that survival depends upon supporting the caregiver.  Instead of focusing energy on self development and awareness, the child must be prepared to respond to what is asked of him or provided to him.  “He loses touch with his own spontaneous needs and gestures,” since these are not functional in responding to the needs of the mother or having her respond to him.  

 

The child learns to meet the needs of the caregiver, whether the need is in the form of grandiosity or helplessness, in order to protect the essence of the child’s self, her “true self”.  Some children are particularly gifted at reading the emotional and narcissistic needs of the parents. Alice Miller, in   The Drama of The Gifted Child writes about how these gifted children are formed and deformed by compliance to external expectations and demands of the parents.   Ministry and other helping professions attract a disproportionate number of such gifted children.  

 

The false self functions  to protect the true self by compliance to the needs of the mother.  When the true self  is hidden or denied, this source of spontaneous thoughts, gestures and needs is protected from the criticism, shame and assault of non-responsiveness.  The true self avoids annihilation by creating a smoke screen of the false self.   At the very least, the false adaptive self assures the tender child that basic needs will be met.  The false self is not satisfying or complete but it can be very successful at performing and receiving external affirmation.  A direct consequence of the false self’s protective function is a heavy reliance on cognitive functions.  With vigilance, the cognitive over functioning can anticipate and react to environmental threat.  Because of the over functioning, the mind becomes overactive and separated from the feelings or bodily functions.  The person may report feelings of hollowness, meaninglessness and emptiness.  There can be may symptoms of an over functioning false self that has eclipsed the true self:  addictions, affairs and risky behavior can be tied to the self's desire to feel something.   If too much of the true self is denied, the spontaneous true self can atrophy.  From lack of care and feeding, the true self becomes almost inaccessible to the person.  There is a sense of being dead inside and flat which can lead to the need for external stimulation and comfort through drugs, alcohol and other self damaging patterns 

 

The child may learn to deny feelings and attempt to be a "good" child.  The child may learn to act bad to deflect from deeper problems in the family.  If the mother uses withdrawal of her affection in order to control the child, the child begins to believe that hating and anger destroy the mother’s love.  Denial of feelings, which are a part of the true self, is preferable to the loss of the mother's love.  

 

“Unthinkable anxiety” is the overwhelming experience of mother’s absence or her excessive intrusiveness.  These are experienced as potential annihilation.  Like abandonment, impingement is intolerable to the child.  Impingement does not allow the self to remain in formlessness and creative omnipotence.  When the  infant is forced to respond to the needs of the mother and forego her own wishes, she may become either too passive or too active, like the child in the example from Stern's who seemed to lose access to her own internal motivation.  The child may be confronted with limitations too soon and too abruptly, which can create problems with relative power in the midst of relative powerlessness.  The child  may form a compliant identity that leads to the development of the “false self”--the imitative compliant hollow self that performs rather than lives.

 

Some people do not move towards the integration of the good and bad internal images of the parent.  They do not accept the ambivalence of situations and the complexity of themselves or others.  Without access to emotions and without responsiveness from the parent figure, loving relationships cannot occur because “care and loving response to mistakes and failures are not forthcoming.”  One couple said that they did not want to learn to handle the conflict that was so prevalent in their marriage--they just wanted it to go away.  “Why do we have to have conflict?” they asked.  Their religious understanding, perhaps grounded in their psychological development, saw conflict as bad and unnecessary.  The problem was that the merger with one another was no longer functional.  One partner began to see her differences from the couple identity and develop some of her own identity; the other partner became blaming.  

 

 

Regression occurs in the adult as a “return to the point at which the environment has failed the child...(where) the absent developmental ‘needs’ dominate subsequent living.”   In Freudian theory, regression is pathological but for Winnecott and others, regression is a normal part of development.  “‘The tendency to regression in a patient is now seen as part of the capacity of the individual to bring about self cure.’”

 

Opportunities for healing and growth occur as the healer offers a small compensatory interventions or environments that modify the patterns of parental or caregiver failures.  Sometimes this occurs unconsciously as the person experiences acceptance and care when they expect censorship and condemnation.  The experience of acceptance, by an individual or with God, is a powerful healing event.  The healer provides a nurturing and honest environment through holding the person in reliable, attentive, responsive, durable ways.   The holding occurs as the healer responds in a slightly different fashion from the internalized images of caregivers from the past.  This can be as small and simple as consistently showing up when she says she will.  The intervention can be more effective and more satisfactory for both giver and receiver when there is intentional assessment, planning and intervention using theory.   I will continue to discuss the ways that the care provider can assess and intervene in a slightly different ways in later chapters.

 

Becoming mature relationships and developing "object constancy" is a life long process.  Constant change occurs in the relational patterns with internal and external objects throughout life.  For this reason, some people seem to be able to sustain a pretty satisfactory balance until an external event occurs that upsets the balance, such as the addition of a child, the adolescent rebellion or the death of a parent.  In a long term committed relationship, such as marriage, both partners must give up the satisfactions and security of one level of relationship when they decide to change roles, to change work positions, to have children or when changes are thrust upon them from illness, accident or loss.  In some ways, there are many different relationships within one partnership.  In each transition there is a challenge and an opportunity to revise the earlier maps of relating and reality.

 

When there has been unthinkable anxiety or other types of  trauma to the person during childhood, the relational patterns become dysfunctional, chaotic and disorganized.  The person's rigid patterns of relating are based on the repressed, submerged internalized patterns that were developed from the past external relationships.  The original reasons for patterns, which are often in the form of splits and projections, are out of awareness, however, they continue to define the person’s attitudes and assumptions.  The diverse form of splits and projections will be developed in later sections. 

 

Some people's whole inner life is dominated by the splits.  

 

Can you identify the splits from your exercise in polarities where you said I am a person who….?  

 

There is a split evident when the hatred of a person alternates with adoration.   There is a split when a grand sense of self laced with entitlement alternates with worthlessness and hopelessness.  When the self is identified as "good", the person feels omnipotent and is at the center of the universe.  This split is tied to gratification and adoration of someone else.  However, these feelings cannot be sustained.  The "all good" alternates with the experience of being "all bad".  Most people carry some residual of this early splitting and projection.  The continuing journey is to continue the integration and modulation in the intensity of the extremes towards more realistically perceived self, other and God.

 

This concludes the overview of early childhood development.  I do not believe that personality development stops or even slows down, at the age of three.   The earliest years provide foundational experiences out of which major life themes are addressed through the life span.  These themes are reworked during the rest of the life span.  In "reworking", I believe that we move towards and away from dynamic tensions, sometimes between apparent opposites....like love and hate, self centered and selfish, etc.  

 

I will use the early development as a foundation to develop several important ways to assess and intervene as a care provider in pastoral relationships.  It is the relationship that creates healing - not insight, or emotional catharsis or self actualization.   

 

We rely upon the power beyond ourselves that woos us towards wholeness and abundant life.  We will be looking at how the relationship can be healing in later chapters.

 

Some authors have said that the entire life cycle can be seen as a more or less successful process of distancing from and taking in the lost idealized mother.  They propose that there is an eternal longing for the actual or fantasized "ideal state of the self" with the latter standing for a symbiotic fusion with the "all good" symbiotic mother, who was at one time part of the self in a blissful state of well being."    Another way to see this would be that we are created to long for, to desire, union with someone who is more than what we can attain in life as we know it.  Perhaps these longings are the foundation of faith, hope and love.  Terri showed me some writings from Julian of Norwich, a 14 century Christian mystic.  These writings about her 16 "showings" or revelations of God's love demonstrate how Julian experienced God and Jesus as mothering love.  One of several quotes captures so much of object relations and offers rich images of God.

 

So in our true Mother Jesus our life is founded in ...his wisdom....  And in accepting our nature he gave us life, and in his blessed dying on the Cross he bore us to endless life. And since that time, now and ever until the day of judgement, he feeds us and fosters us, just as the great supreme lovingness of motherhood wishes, and as the natural need of childhood asks.  Fair and sweet is our heavenly Mother in sight of our soul, precious and lovely are the children of grace in sight of our heavenly Mother, with gentleness and meekness and all the lovely virtues which belong to children by nature.  For the child does not naturally despair of the mother's love, the child does not naturally rely upon itself, naturally the child loves the mother and either of them the other. Julian of Norwich, Showings p. 304"

 

God is always “more than” any one image or understanding that we can have. 

 

The next section addressing “splitting” which is one core way we defend against powerlessness and shame.   Cathy

 

 

 

 

Interesting:  

“The Power Pivot” was Margaret Mahler’s term for the crucial relationship challenges and changes around 15 -36 months.  “Rapprochement” is a French word that refers to the renewal of relationship between two states or parties, usually after a conflict or abandonment. These terms capture the complexity of this time of development.  

 

Daniel Stern uses the phrase, “The Sense of a Verbal Self” for this period from about 15-18 months to three  years of age.

(Daniel Stern in Diary of a Baby, age 20 months) 

 

Kernberg lists some of the benefits of maturity or tasks of childhood which may be helpful to us as we provide pastoral care:

1  self-object differentiation, which would include the ability to identify physical and emotional boundaries.

2.  internalization of the good and bad mother, which is a prerequisite for approaching complexity and ambiguity in relationship to other people.

3.  integration of ambiguities which means that the person comes to terms with the good and bad in others.

4.  object constancy which allows the person to carry others within the self to use as a resource to endure absence, separation and loss. 

 

 

  "Rather than seeing the relationship as a means of facilitating object relations views the relationship ITSELF as the focus of treatment." 

 

Back