I have created the table as I explored how the elements and the principles interact to affect composition. So when I think about seeking the principle of BALANCE in a composition, I can look to the element of SHAPE. Strong composition uses a few elements well.
The challenge is compressing a great deal of thought to the point it become unintelligible.
TO get an initial handle on the table, look at the principle of DEPTH.
If you look down the table under DEPTH, you will see how to use each element to create depth, or the illusion of distance in a visual piece. I have worked out the ideas for depth most thoroughly.
The rest are less clear and is in constant revision.
|
Principles (across)
ELEMENTS (down) |
BaLaNce/imbalance |
MOVEMENT/static |
EMPHASIS/d* |
Repetition/no |
DEPTH/Flatness |
MOOD: |
|
SHAPE /line Negative AND Positive can be organic, geometric, Circle -sphere, cylinder, cone or triangle, Square or cube – rect - odd |
The character of the shapes draws or loses the viewer’ attention |
Movement found/lost Through Repetition use direction: horizontal, vertical, diagonal, curving, perpendicular, oblique, parallel, radial, zigzag |
Dominance Contrast (provides emphasis and emphasis provides balnce Equal/unequal |
Rhythm, movement
Gives harmony or not Simplicity or NOT Reinforces patterns |
D - More vague outlines 3rd dimension of shadowing |
Harmony Discord, Diversity Similarity Variety sameness |
|
SIZE Small – large - medium |
Visual weight |
Through Rhythm, repetition Graduation |
Contrast Unequal amts |
Large or small |
D-Smaller is receding |
Massive Insignificant |
|
TEXTURE Rough, smooth, irregular, slick, soft, hard, fluffy, …. |
Calls Attention so can create balance |
Through Repetition |
Contrast Unequal amts |
Smooth or rough Soft or hard |
D-Less detail in distance |
complexity, Energy, Harmony discord |
|
COLOR |
Attraction |
Graduation |
|
|
|
|
|
VALUE |
Weight = Dark Light = lite |
Rhythm, repetition |
Contrast USE Unequal amts |
Lt or dk |
D-lighter |
Feelings of light Darkness |
|
HUE |
Warm – heavy Cool - lite |
Rhythm, repetition |
Contrast Unequal amts |
Cool or warm |
D-cooler |
Feelings of warm cool |
|
INTENSITY |
Bright – lite Dull - heavy |
Rhythm, repetition Alternation |
Contrast Variations repetition |
Dull or bright (key) |
D-More dull |
State of Energy |
|
DIRECTION- of other elements? horizontal, vertical or oblique dominant direction |
Draws attention to one or more places |
Created by Graduation Direct lines Pointers implied lines |
Contrasts Unequal amts |
Vertical, horizontal or angular Bold or Subtle |
D-Diagonal converging lines -perspective |
State of Energy, |
|
PLACEMENT |
Draws attention.
(COI and rule of thirds) |
Groupings Alternation/ Lt-Dark |
Contrasts Unequal amts |
Empty or full Emphasis on foreground or background (sky) |
) most D at horizon
overlapping |
State of Isolation community |
Let me know what you see and what you are thinking, painting, experiementing with...surprise me.
More reflections on composition:
I spent a few years refuting the importance of learning composition, seeing only restrictions and structures. Then I had a conversion as I realized that composition is just understanding how we SEE. For many years I explored visual composition.
Some people don't care about composition and a subset of them seem to "get it" without any conscious intention. I have come to believe that the rules of composition are not rules but knowledge that can be used or discarded with some intentionality.
I have to work hard at composition and my progress is slow.
I was not naturally good at composition. I studied, read, took notes, took courses, experienced wondered and remained confused. I am still learning.
Composition theory seems to be about understanding the relationship between the artist and the viewer, and about the artist and the subject. Essentially the references, the theory, makes concrete how the eye and the brain work. whether you like them or not, they exist.
The viewer is entering a relationship with the artist through the subject. The viewer seeks some experience, some SURPRISE ME, but not too much confusion; “don't overwhelm me…but keep me interested. A subject that overwhelms one viewer might bore another, and experience with the subject, the materials increases the tolerance and enjoyment of variety. The “edge of the unknown” has moved farther for people who have explored the territory. "Understanding" may be a longing that some folks bring to the subject. For others understanding is far to tame a goal. They want to be intrigued, engaged, pressed, pushed little out of their familiar world view. If a piece is too easily understood by you, it is boring.
The more exposure I have with the medium, subject, disciple (visual arts, music, even theology,) the more variety I can enjoy!
In this conversation with a visual subject, the "words" of communication might be the elements and principles of art. I have played with a table of how the elements and principles might offset or interact with one another.
At the core there seems to be a dance between the human need for:
Harmony and Variety
Clarity, stability, sameness, predictability, recognition and Novelty, interest, innovation,
Convergent Consonance and Divergent Dissonance
Closeness Nurture and Distance Challenge
Rhythm, Dominance and repetition are used to Contrast, imbalance, movement, emphasis are used to
create order out of forces in opposition create interest through opposition
There is a need for more or less balance and for places within a piece where there is static energy, where the eye can rest,
There are cues to the view such as graduation and repetition that point to the center of interest.
|
What makes an image interesting? Contrasts help. Contrast maybe visual - that of color, shape, size, light and dark. An image may have more symbolic contrasts - poverty and riches, good and evil, loss and gain.
Contrast: The greater the difference, the more attention the area attract; therefore the center of interest, where the eye stays in the picture will be at the point of greates contrast. If you don't plan the conversation the center of interest may be outside the picture frame! |
CONTRASTS:
|
Point/Line Plane/Volume Large/Small High/Low Long/Short Broad/Narrow Thick/Thin Light/Dark Black/White Much/Little Straight/Curved Pointed/Blunt Horizontal/Diagonal Diagonal/Circular Area/Line Area/Body Line/Body Smooth/Rough Hard/Soft Still/Moving Light/Heavy Transparent/Opaque Continuous/Intermittent Liquid/Solid Sweet/Sour Strong/Weak Loud/Soft |
I'd love to hear other folks reflections on these ideas!
Cathy
Bob Burris
Set the Title before starting to know when painting is done; matches the title
ONE BIG idea
Make a series
Stick to it
Set the structure:
There are:
12 compositions: 1 or at most 2
1.crucifix
2.cantilever
3.overlapping squares
4. curves like spaghetti
6. verticals trees, vases
7. diagonal
8.constellation lots of many things
9. squiggly
10. golden section focal point at sweet spot
11. tension: off balance: looks like it is going to fall, unstable
12. portraiture; in the center.
Follow the color wheel
Color combination:
Use wheel
basic decide:
Monochrome
four colors touching analogue
complementary: opposites
Triadic: every fourth color starting anywhere
RED, Yellow, Blue
dominant color with spice colors.
80%
(His has only 10 colors to match Holbein oil paints
with spinning )
all over painting pulls it together…